Even if you are complementarian, this book is full of cringy beliefs. If you are not complementarian, it is misogynistic. I would be curious to see an updated argument from complementarians without their "women need to be in the home" mantra. Or perhaps they still believe that....
I put moderate misogyny because the authors do show respect about the concept of women; it's the practical side that becomes tricky. I know that sounds weird, but if you read it you'll understand
The concept for this story was really fascinating. However, I think it was a movie made into a graphic novel, and it didn't translate well. There were moments that were confusing or supposed to be funny but werent because it needed the movie aspect and not a drawn one.
I also don't like it when shows play with history and drastically change it, especially when it comes to kids things. They had lord Cromwell die at the end, and that didn't happen in real life. I'm an historian, so things like that matter to me.
Unfortunately, it probably accurately described Cromwell's fanatic religiousity. As a Christian, it was painful to read, but it's time Christians face the issues we've created rather than telling an alternate story. (It's also why telling the truth of history, despite it being a work of fiction, is so important).
This was good, but it's definitely dated in some respects. I'm not sure I would say this is for children, as it would definitely require some explanation on the part of the parents. See content warnings for details.
Kidnapping: the kidnapping was kinda creepy, and knowing that this sort of thing happens in real life (for non-fantasy purposes) was really creepy.
Racism: the children talk casually in the first few chapters of "natives" and say some flippantly derogatory things. It's definitely inappropriate by today's standards and should be discussed with any child who reads it.
Oh my goodness I LOVED this book!! It was so beautiful and poignant satisfying. I was nervous with some of the reviews, but it was simply wonderful.
I want to address the content warnings of rape/sexual violence. When Chris joins with the sun, it is clearly painful for her, but it is not a graphic rendering of what a sexual assault would be. It's also clear that it's consensual. The sun cannot help but be what he is - which is a firey ball of light. It's kind of complicated to explain, but I imagined it like she was being consumed by a fire. Ceris did have some feelings that a survivor of violence would have, so that may have been what confused people and made them uncomfortable. I'm not sure why it was written that way, although the entire book seemed to be about processing trauma. It was really poignant in that respect. However, this fantasy trauma was removed enough from real trauma so that it wasn't too uncomfortable to process through. I would like Ceris's experience to a surgery or chemo - something that does cause trauma but something you choose out of necessity.
There is one almost assault scene, but Ceris escapes almost as soon as she is grabbed, and it is on earth. So I really don't know why people are giving a graphic rating to rape/sexual violence.
This was interesting, but very dry. Also, it is very old and I began to wonder how much the information has changed as our knowledge has surely grown since the time this was written