Scan barcode
imyourmausoleum's review against another edition
informative
reflective
slow-paced
4.0
This book takes a deep dive into the end of World War II in the European Theatre. Germany in the time of Nazi rule was a place of hatred, blind obedience, fear tactics, and cruelty that resulted in genocide and slave labor. People's rights were stripped away and wild laws were enacted, the likes of which society hoped to never see again (though it is playing out in real time in several places around the globe as we speak). The last few months of the war, anyone could see that it was very clearly a lost cause, but Germany simply refused to give up...pulling elderly people and children out to fight in various capacities. Looking back, that seems insane, but that is what happens with you have a megalomaniac in control, I guess. It was very interesting to look at the many reasons people attempted to keep this war going, against all odds. It includes some quotes and conversations with people who were living in and serving Germany in various military capacities, which I loved. I think personal accounts are so important to the historical narrative, as well as just for simply understanding eras and mindsets different than our own or what we live in.
Ian Kershaw is one of my favorite historians. Everything I have read from this author has been enlightening. I first came across this author when I was looking for something for a project I had to do in one of my World War II classes, which was my specialization at the time. I have used his work as a source in several papers in my historical education, and I find great value in his writing. This book is well researched, beautifully written, informative, and offers up a lot of really valid points. If you are interested in World War II or need source material, especially in regards to the end of the war and Germany's capitulation, I would strongly suggest checking out this book. I actually have the Audible version of this book, and it was wonderful to listen to, even if was quite long.
Ian Kershaw is one of my favorite historians. Everything I have read from this author has been enlightening. I first came across this author when I was looking for something for a project I had to do in one of my World War II classes, which was my specialization at the time. I have used his work as a source in several papers in my historical education, and I find great value in his writing. This book is well researched, beautifully written, informative, and offers up a lot of really valid points. If you are interested in World War II or need source material, especially in regards to the end of the war and Germany's capitulation, I would strongly suggest checking out this book. I actually have the Audible version of this book, and it was wonderful to listen to, even if was quite long.
troy66's review against another edition
4.0
This book explained why the Nazi's and Germany continued to fight despite it being obvious they had lost. The assassination attempt on Hitler seemed to draw people closer to him. If he had died then the 3rd Reich would fail. It also started his major followers to consolidate and expand their power. There are plenty of military histories about the last days of the Reich but only this one explaining why they fought to the end and were willing to let Germany be destroyed rather then surrender.
kathykekmrs's review against another edition
4.0
I enjoyed reading about the various reasons Germany chose not to end the Second World War sooner than May 1945. There are many things to think about in this book.
brownboydigital's review against another edition
4.0
This is one of the best Ian Kershaw books I have read. He presented the information in a very clear and easy-to-understand way, as well as making it an interesting narrative to follow. In some sequences, it felt like watching a movie. My only caveat to this would be the amount of repetition that was used to hammer down points.
Overall, a very good book that I suggest people to read
Overall, a very good book that I suggest people to read
kazeneko20's review against another edition
3.0
This book is well written in such a way as to keep a readers interest. And is an interesting approach to the end of the war. However I found it to be lacking in cohesion. This book has a lot of well researched information however it could have been condensed into half the number of pages.
Some interesting points where
Pg 14 In speaking as to why the leadership held out "They were sustained in the main not blind Faith in hitler. More important for arch nazis was the feeling that they had the future without hitler. provided a powerful negative bond their fates were inextricably linked.
And on pg 379
In the 10 months between July 1944 and May 1945 for more German civilians died than in previous years of the war mostly through air raids and the calamitous conditions in the eastern front after January 1945 and all more than 400,000 were killed and 800,00 injured".
Some interesting points where
Pg 14 In speaking as to why the leadership held out "They were sustained in the main not blind Faith in hitler. More important for arch nazis was the feeling that they had the future without hitler. provided a powerful negative bond their fates were inextricably linked.
And on pg 379
In the 10 months between July 1944 and May 1945 for more German civilians died than in previous years of the war mostly through air raids and the calamitous conditions in the eastern front after January 1945 and all more than 400,000 were killed and 800,00 injured".
tanyarobinson's review against another edition
3.0
In this heavy volume, Kershaw (Hitler specialist extraordinaire) traces the decline of the German war machine from the July 1944 failed assassination attempt to the final surrender in May 1945. He sets out to answer the intriguing question, "Why did Germany keep fighting so long after their defeat was obvious and inevitable?"
I will say that I was intrigued by that question when I began the book. Now I feel like it has been beaten into the ground. The End is thorough to the extreme, and became redundant as we moved month by month through fanatical obedience and cowed passivity in the face of declining fortunes. I certainly can't fault Kershaw's scholarship, but - like the people of the bombed and battered German cities - I just wanted it to be over!
I will say that I was intrigued by that question when I began the book. Now I feel like it has been beaten into the ground. The End is thorough to the extreme, and became redundant as we moved month by month through fanatical obedience and cowed passivity in the face of declining fortunes. I certainly can't fault Kershaw's scholarship, but - like the people of the bombed and battered German cities - I just wanted it to be over!
jonahbarnes's review against another edition
challenging
dark
emotional
informative
reflective
sad
Fascinating. A helpful perspective of the war.