I read this poorly for the first half (in small chunks) and then in one or two grand sweeps during the second half and this affected my feelings towards the book. If I had read it in greater chunks then I think I would have given it a higher rating. The writing is very well done and the characters are all well drawn, it's pacey (esp. the second half) and it's clear that Westall knows his history. The place, artefacts and people certainly felt like 'real' people. A few words may be questionable when read in class but careful planning would avoid these issues.

Circe is a wonderfully feminist retelling of a classic Greek myth. I was only vaguely familiar with The Odessey to the extent that I knew who the main players were in the story. I didn’t know anything about Circe as a character and, to be honest, I was drawn to this book because it was shortlisted for the women’s prize for fiction. That and the cover art. I knew I would love it. It didn’t disappoint.

From the very first page you can tell what a special book this is: Madeline Miller’s skilful and elegant language is enviable. She masterfully fleshes out a lifetime of story about a character who was no more than a passing lover of Odysseus on his way back to Ithaca.

Circe’s island of Aiaia is vividly described and her experiences are varied despite her banishment. In parts such as her voyage to see her sister and her involvement with the Minotaur the novel is adventurous, whilst in other parts it is a romantic love story. Mostly, though, I think it is a coming of age tale in which Circe turns Helios’ rejection of her on its head - in the end is is she who is strongest and needs no approval from her Titan father.

I will look out for future books from Miller - she’s a stunning writer.

I really enjoyed this book. Considering it's written for kids it has some very adult scenes and content, which was quite surprising to find in children's fiction. However, the characters were all unique and well-written, helping to give a fascinating lifelike insight into everyday British life during the war.

Reread on 4th September 2014

This story takes place in Garmouth during the Second World War. The kids collect war souvenirs such as incendiary bombs, plane fins, smashed bullets and other stuffs. Boddser Brown has the best war souvenir because he found the nose-cone of a 3.7 inch anti-aircraft shell. But when Chas McGill stumbles on a machine gun from a shot-down German plane, he and his friends built a fortress for the machine-gun. They brilliantly outwitted the police, parents and school members. Then Rudi, a German survivor found their fortress and Rudi lived there. Suspicion arouses the police and parents, as slowly the mystery reveals from accidents and missing objects. They had became the machine-gunners, and with it a lot of trouble came.

Pure brilliance!

The Machine Gunners is Robert Westall’s first novel about World War II. It is set in the town of Garmouth, a seaside town in northern England. Though fictional, it is modeled on Tynemouth, the town where Westall grew up during the war.

The novel begins the morning after an air-raid. Before school starts, Chas (Charles) McGill, 14, goes off to collect souvenirs, things like bits of shrapnel or incendiary bomb fins from the raid. Chas has the second best collection in school, so when he stumbles upon the engines of a German plane, he thinks he has hit pay dirt, until he discovers that one has been claimed by a boy and the other engine is being guarded by the Constable Fatty Hardy, who starts chasing him.

Running off, Chas heads for a wood, where he knows he can hide and as luck would have it, he finds the rest of the German plane. Not only that, but the plane’s machine gun is still there and intact. Thinking it would be quite a souvenir, Chas tries to detach it, until he realizes that the pilot is still in the cockpit. The sight of the dead pilot shakes Chas up, but he runs off only because he realizes he needs to get to school.

After school, Chas and his friends “Cem” (short for Cemetery, his dad is the local undertaker) Jones and Audrey Parton return to the wood to retrieve the machine gun. Taking turns sawing it off, they finally free the gun and sneak it out of the wood up the leg of Cem’s Guy Fawkes effigy.* They get caught in an air-raid by Chas’ father, who takes the Guy and puts it in his greenhouse for safe keeping. The next morning Chas hides the machine gun in an old drain pipe. A few days later, Cem tells Chas he had returned to the plane and found four thousand rounds of ammunition clips for the gun.

Out of necessity, the group has grown to include Chas, Cem, Audrey, “Clogger” Duncan, a boy from Scotland sent to live with his aunt, a redheaded boy named Carrot Juice and Nicky. The fortress is being put together quite nicely when Nicky’s house is destroyed in an air-raid and the authorities think he has been crushed to death in the debris. Nicky decides to “stay dead” and hide so that he won’t be sent away. Clogger, unhappy living with his aunt, decides to move into the fortress with Nicky.

After the fortress is finished, the kids spend their free time watching out for German planes. When one finally appears, Chas starts shooting the machine gun, missing it but scaring the pilot into making an error and causing the plane to be brought down by anti-aircraft. The rear gunner, Sergeant Rudi Gerlath, manages to parachute out of the plane just before it explodes. Injured, he is force to spend a week hiding out in a rabbit hutch on a victory garden allotment, eating frozen Brussels sprouts he finds growing there. When he is finally able, he wanders about, wondering what to do. Cold and tired, he eventually finds the fortress, wraps himself up in the blankets he finds there and falls asleep.

When the kids to find Rudi, the first thing they do is take his gun away. Disappointed that Rudi doesn’t look like the Nazis in films, the kids hold him prisoner anyway. And, after a while, seeing that Rudi is not in good shape, they begin taking care of him. After they discover he knows some English, they begin to get pretty comfortable with each other, hanging out, keeping watch and reading comic books. Living in the fortress with Clogger and Nicky, Rudi realizes, is a good place - it's warm, comfortable and there is always food to eat.
But the attack on his plane leaves the machine gun broken and it doesn’t take Chas long to figure out that Rudi could fix it. Rudi really doesn’t want to do this, but Chas makes a deal – they will provide Rudi with a sail boat he can use to escape to Norway if he fixes the machine gun.

Rudi puts off doing this for as long as possible, but one night there is another raid. This one is the worst Garmouth has had to date. Suddenly, the church bells could be heard tolling, the signal that the Germans were invading England. The kids race to their fortress to defend themselves. Chas tells Rudi the time has come to fix the machine gun. Believing the Germans are invading helps Rudi overcome his reluctance at letting the kids have such a powerful gun. When he finishes, they take him down to the harbor and give him the promised boat. Rudi soon realizes he hasn’t got enough strength to get to sail to Norway and returns to the fortress. But, unbeknownst to him and the kids, the tolling church bells had been a false alarm and the kids are reported missing. Now, Constable Fatty Hardy enlists members of the Free Polish Army to help look for them. The kids see them in foreign looking uniforms and believe Fatty Hardy is a quisling and the Polish soldiers are German. Needless to say, chaos reigns supreme from this point on, with a bit of a surprise ending.

Robert Westall wrote one of my favorite World War II novels, Blitzcat. There, he gave us an endearing kitty that changed lives of those she came into contact with as she traveled across southern England searching for her one true owner, who is serving in the army. In The Machine Gunners, Chas does not have that same endearing quality, even though he has the same single minded focus on getting his machine gun to work. Yet, looking past his selfishness, Chas is really just a scared 13 year old trying to make a safe, secure place for himself in a world at war, where the next bomb could be the one that destroys your whole life.

This book is recommended for readers ages 12 and up.
This book was purchased for my personal library.

Robert Westall received the following well-deserved awards for The Machine Gunners:
1975 CILIP Carnegie Medal
1975 Runner-up Guardian Award
1977 Boston Globe Horn Book Award Honor Book
1989 Preis der Leseratten 1989
2007 Carnegie Medal 70th Anniversary 2007 Top Ten

I was thinking about books I've read and this came to mind and I must be honest I'm ashamed that it took me so long to think of it! It's one I read at about 10 years of age and it made a big impact on my imagination and creates feelings of nostalgia in me.

The story revolves around Chas McGill and his discovery of a crashed Luftwaffe plane and it's machine gun.

Bought it while travelling. Nice short story, I really liked the writing style.