Too much dialogue that doesn't serve to advance the plot, and at this point there are far too many characters that we never really get to know. Add on the fact that the characters are written to be complete morons just to fall victim to the villains, to advance the story, as well. There is also a really annoying moment when the characters have a tarot reading, while the villain is wreaking havoc and going on a massacre, just to arrive at an incredibly obvious conclusion.
The characters are incompetent and hard to root for, and I'm not really enjoying where the story is going, but I will finish this series, as there are only two remaining issues.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.5
This would have been a really solid thriller, had I not disagreed with the representation of some of the Gotham legacy characters: Alfred, who gives up on an angry young Bruce and leaves, further fueling Bruce's anger and issues of abandonment, and Detective Gordon, who leaves the police force in disgrace, and seemingly gives up on Gotham. The artwork and some of the spreads and panel layouts are phenomenal, though! Sorrentino is a brilliant choice to illustrate a gritty, noir, detective story, so Gotham is rendered expertly, and with Bellaire doing colors and Wands the lettering, this miniseries is a seriously impressive visual feast. There are also some really great side characters that leave quite an impact, though I wasn't sold on one of the relationships. Overall, this is worth the read for the presentation alone, but especially for anyone wanting a dark, gritty Batman noir.
Wasn't a big fan of the first story - it was a modern take on "A Picture of Dorian Gray" that didn't really land, and needed a rewrite - but the second story was possibly my favorite story of the entire run: a debutante ball that evolves into a bloody ball; the art was absolutely killer for that one too!
One of my favorite issues of this series so far! The first story is a really fun vampire tale; the second is a really unique blend of horror and luchador wrestling!
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
Excellent grab for anyone missing classic horror comics! The first story is very true-to-form for the genre, giving us a perfect Halloween read; the second story is fun and campy.