Occasionally quite odd to read - due in part to the nature of transcribing lectures and publishing them as books, and in part to the curiosities of translation (I've learned many mostly useless new words in my native language, and shudder at the thought of doing the same in French) - but absolutely fascinating. I've brought these ideas up in conversation several times already, and have been pleased by how easily understood they were, despite Foucault and his translator insisting on my learning words like etiology and concupiscence and onanism.
The writing is bad, the romance is worse - but I read the whole thing in a couple hours and immediately started the sequel. Some really great horror scenes, at least in concept. I'm excited for the rest of the series, to see the author come into their own
Better than the first book. Still a dodgy romance, the writing still isn't great, but the concept is fun and you can tell the writer will be great once they've practiced more
I'd give it four stars if it wasn't for the weird Druid obsession - which again it would be fine if the writer framed it more clearly as pretty naïve American kids getting excited about another culture's mysticism. I'm not offended by it, but speaking as a Scot it's just weird to read about Bonnie's grandmother in Edinburgh teaching her *the old ways*
In all honesty, it's probably a better book than I'm giving credit for. It was nice to read about a disabled character, and depictions of queerness, in a fairly matter of fact way. But the actual story and style were incredibly boring to read, to the point of me skimming most of it, and the language (though standard for its time) now seems so outdated that it was deeply uncomfortable to read.
The stories don't stand on their own very well, but for fans of the series they're some great extra content, with some interesting theories on aspects of the franchise that had not yet been answered. Bit of a time capsule also - moments of sexism (to modern audiences) are perhaps more overt in prose than they were on screen, which is not exactly comfortable to read, but considering the time period I won't let that overly affect my opinion. Certainly, an attempt was made to be inclusive to all people, and while that doesn't work in the same way today, the attempt is to be respected