I enjoy the plot of this series, and this installment was very action-packed. But I have realized since I started the series that I am a closed-door romance person, and this is very, very steamy. If rating based on plot and overall writing, 4/5. If rating the book/series as it is written, 2/5 maybe? I am not going to rate because it wasn't written for someone who doesn't like a very steamy book. This one contains a pregnancy, which is very not my thing.
Woolf has a style of writing that is extremely stream-of-consciousness, which isn't for everyone. Lots of tangents and run-off ideas that she brings back around to incorporate into her argument. It can be a bit repetitive.
The content of this is good though. Her thesis is that in order to succeed in an artistic endeavor like writing, a woman needs time, space, and income. She can't be a busy mother, she can't need to work for a living, and she can't be controlled by a spouse as property without her own agency.
Based on the time this was written (1928), it's great. Looking at it through a modern lens brings up some questions of racism and intersectionality.
I laughed constantly throughout, and read this from start to finish in 7 hours nonstop (I took a personal day). As always, Emily Henry writes characters and family dynamics like no one else. This is exactly the type of romance I love, with similar vibes to Book Lovers, which I also gave 5 stars.
This was good, it is an exploration of the lives of a specific handful of regency-adjacent women. I don't think "Princess Caraboo" should have been included. There were a couple times I felt the editing could have been better, where a sentence was unclear. Overall I enjoyed learning about these women and how they rebelled against what was expected of them in their own ways.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
I love this series. WW isn't overly sexualized, and her flaws are shown as well as her considerable strengths. She makes mistakes although she has the best intentions. She still wins in the end and is such an amazing character.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
The first half of this had me giggling and riveted and absolutely obsessed. However the second half dragged, the plot took a back seat, and the main focus was the physical chemistry and sex scenes between the MCs. 400 pages is a lot for a romance, and I think 50-100 pages of smut and repeated dialogue could have been cut out without losing anything from the story.