I overall enjoyed the story. At times I was confused, the ending leaves me wanting a bit more information about what’s going to happen with these characters now. The beginning of the book feels like a completely different story to the end of the book. The main character has really bad headaches, but that kinda gets forgotten? It could have worked it’s way into the plot really well though. Sydney kinda just disappeared after her important moments. Like we don’t even know if she got told everything that happened with the experiments and what she did I really enjoyed the premise, I think it could have just been a little tighter overall
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
I loved this book so much!! The only reason I’m giving it a 4.5 and not a 5 is because I think a few things could have been put together a little better. But the ending was amazing, it felt that maybe a few moments maybe had to get cut from the books? No resolution for certain characters, but hopefully we’ll get to see them again in a possibly future novella? Either way loved it!
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
My jaw will not close! The way Stephanie Garber can create such a magical and fantastical world that has me enthralled to the very end is truly a gift! I am screaming about this ending holy shit! Jaw on the floor! As an unrelated note the song Carve a Smile by Shayfer James is Jacks’s theme song and no one can change my mind ahhhhhhhh
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
The therapy aspects within this book were done every well, I think anyone going through something similar as Persephone then reading those words would feel seen and heard.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
A rich fantastical world that is built upon as you read each chapter and discover more with each new character. This is such a unique way to write a book and share diverse perspectives and experiences! All of these authors did such an amazing job and creating a beautifully lush magic system and magical world full of creatures, to world building, making me want more information as I get to each new character! The mystery of this book was very good (I’m proud cause I kinda guessed it) the ending of the mystery fell kind of flat for me only because it’s hard to wrap up a mystery where you don’t have a focus on a main character. Hense why I gave 4.5 stars. But overall this book is wonderfully beautiful!
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.0
Maybe this book just wasn’t for me… I could see it being a story about life and death, but the amount of paragraphs I read where by the end I was overall confused with what I had just read is too many to count. It’s a beautiful story, maybe one that I’d have to read again to fully grasp. I did not think there had to be that much to do with sex? It just seemed like it didn’t really fit into the plot for me? But maybe I miss understood the reasoning Mrs. Dingles has my heart though.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
I haven’t had a book in a while that made me actively scream at the characters, cringe, feel second hand embarrassment and cry and to say the least it was wonderful!! The twists and turns within the last 10 chapters is something I never would have expected, I knew shit was about to go down, but not in the way it did!! I loved this book!
The ending felt a tiny bit rushed. But I do understand that endings can be hard. You have a big reveal and then gotta figure out how to nicely wrap it all up in a satisfying way. Overall it was a really nice quick read. I enjoyed the relationships between characters. I think if anything Joss and Jerichos relationship could have progressed in a more satisfying way.
I found this to be a very easy read which was enjoyable. I liked how the characters evolved and how the story unfolded and though at times the story beats were predictable I don’t think that harmed the book in anyways. I find it fun when authors leave bread crumbs for the reads to piece the story together and it’s very satisfying as a reader to know that I was right and able to pick up on it all!! Can’t wait to start the sequel!!