Maybe it was the language barrier, but I absolutely couldn't follow what happend. To me the story felt confusing with very few explanations about the sirens and it quickly became exhausting to read.
As a non-native speaker, the first 100 pages were quite difficult for me. This book purposely uses a lot of Brooklyn Slang and I personally needed to get used to that. But once you're in it - you're IN it. It's music and black culture in the streets of New York - captured so vividly and gripping, sad and brutal and sweet. I couldn't put it down.
The "alien-comes-to-earth-the-first-time"-concept is nothing new (in fact, I had to think of Marvel's first Thor movie a lot while reading this), but Matt Haig manages to put an interesting spin on it. It's funny and philosophical in a way that will stick with me for a long time. It DOES have its lenghts though and the last few pages contained some of the cringiest sentences I've ever read. I also think that it focused on the protagonist a bit toooo much and neglected the development of some side characters.
It's beautiful and raw and emotional. I'm a slow reader and I finished it in less than two days - the story seemed to haunt me whenever I dared to take a break or make myself a cup of tea. It's unlike anything I've ever read - scary, suspenseful and sometimes even funny. The only thing that threw me off was the ending, because I wanted a few things to be different. However, I respect the risks the author takes. I love this book, the story will stay with me for a long time.
Having been a subscriber to her YouTube channel for longer than I remember, I was very excited for this book. Regardless of my opinion on the story, I'm incredibly happy that she now has multiple books published and that she is living her dream as an author.
The writing style is whimsical in the best way, I enjoyed the way she told the different events and timelines. The story itself however is flawed to me, confusing at times. As much as I wanted to like it, I couldn't ignore some of the questionable decisions that were made. I also miss that there wasn't a specific time (at least decade) where the storylines takes place, as I very much struggled to imagine the places and characters without this context. Nonetheless, there were some brilliant chapters that I like very much.
I've read this book multiple times and always discovered a new perspective on the events taking place. I still feel like I haven't yet understood the story completely (which means that I need to read it a few more times still, I suppose) but it somehow sticks with me in a very special way. It has been and forever will be one of my favourite books.
I listened to the audiobook, so I have to add that Carrie Hope Fletcher as Tiffy was really enjoyable and calming to listen to.
All in all, this was a fun experience and can see myself recommending this to friends who love romance novels - for me personally though, it didn't quite catch me enough to really like it.
Fucking intense. Incredible characters that felt unique and three-dimensional. I was hooked as soon as I picked it up and developed a connection to every person in this book (especially loved Frances' mum, how dare she be so cool).
The only criticism I have is that some of the revelations and twists of the story were easy to guess (at least for me), I wanted to be a bit more surprised. Sometimes the book felt a bit preachy with its message about university and choosing one's own path, but since I can very much relate to the character's struggles, I didn't mind it much.