Scan barcode
A review by mmccombs
Nuclear War : A Scenario by Annie Jacobsen
dark
reflective
sad
medium-paced
4.0
Well… I really think we should not do nuclear war.
In all seriousness, this was probably not the greatest book to read while already spiraling about the climate crisis and increased hostility around the globe, but I do feel slightly more informed and definitely more alarmed about the mere existence of nuclear weapons. I kept coming back to that scene at the end of Oppenheimer when he tells Einstein that that they likely did usher in the destruction of the world with the creation of the atomic bomb, because that felt truer than ever as I went through the book.
Seeing a step-by-step scenario play was incredibly chilling and also just terrifyingly realistic (even though all of the worst possible scenarios were the ones that played out). I did think the writing was a bit over the top, and some of her comments on North Korea seemed just kind of out of place, especially in a made up scenario (like please don’t even quote from Joe Rogan’s podcast even in passing please). After just reading Challenger by Adam Higginbotham, which set a high bar for gripping scientific nonfiction, I feel like the writing and journalism was just not as well organized or paced as I would have hoped. Ultimately, I ended this book feeling entirely upset but also more informed, though unsure exactly where to go from here with this knowledge. Just panic I guess??
In all seriousness, this was probably not the greatest book to read while already spiraling about the climate crisis and increased hostility around the globe, but I do feel slightly more informed and definitely more alarmed about the mere existence of nuclear weapons. I kept coming back to that scene at the end of Oppenheimer when he tells Einstein that that they likely did usher in the destruction of the world with the creation of the atomic bomb, because that felt truer than ever as I went through the book.
Seeing a step-by-step scenario play was incredibly chilling and also just terrifyingly realistic (even though all of the worst possible scenarios were the ones that played out). I did think the writing was a bit over the top, and some of her comments on North Korea seemed just kind of out of place, especially in a made up scenario (like please don’t even quote from Joe Rogan’s podcast even in passing please). After just reading Challenger by Adam Higginbotham, which set a high bar for gripping scientific nonfiction, I feel like the writing and journalism was just not as well organized or paced as I would have hoped. Ultimately, I ended this book feeling entirely upset but also more informed, though unsure exactly where to go from here with this knowledge. Just panic I guess??
Graphic: Death, Genocide, and Medical trauma