Scan barcode
A review by katerzjoy
The Last Witch in Edinburgh by Marielle Thompson
emotional
hopeful
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25
A journey with witches through time. From witch trials to today. Examining the attack upon women with the only reason being their gender. A strong feminist account of how patriarchy works against everyone and the participation from all to continue it. This book captures feminine rage, pain, fear and joy perfectly leaving me in tears at times. Great representation for LGBTQIA+, chronic pain and loss. Characters are complex with a history and rich emotions. Despite the main characters and plot line being witch/gods driven the story remains relatable with the plot line being for everyone. A perfect ending that doesn’t rely on a magical solution but an every day one.
Where it lost me was the “woah is me I’m too pretty”. While I appreciate the hazard it brings along with its privilege the main character was singularly focused upon her own beauty and others. Further perpetuating the oppression. She recognizes it is wrong, yet continues it.
The other concern I had was with the main relationship. It felt more of a matter of circumstance rather than compatibility. They want each other to be what they aren’t and are cruel to each other for not meeting those expectations. While there is growth it is not because of a healthy relationship.
Thank you Kensington Publishing for the opportunity to provide and honest and free review for the opportunity to receive a free advanced reader copy via NetGalley
Where it lost me was the “woah is me I’m too pretty”. While I appreciate the hazard it brings along with its privilege the main character was singularly focused upon her own beauty and others. Further perpetuating the oppression. She recognizes it is wrong, yet continues it.
The other concern I had was with the main relationship. It felt more of a matter of circumstance rather than compatibility. They want each other to be what they aren’t and are cruel to each other for not meeting those expectations. While there is growth it is not because of a healthy relationship.
Thank you Kensington Publishing for the opportunity to provide and honest and free review for the opportunity to receive a free advanced reader copy via NetGalley