I gave it four stars because it is such a clear and well orchestrated picture of a specific time and lifestyle. The writing is masterful. It didn't get the fifth star from me because the lifestyle is something that annoys me. I hate the pretension and the conspicuous consumption that is central to the storyline. It's a classic but, had it not been required reading in high school, I would never have chosen to immerse myself in something that rubs me the wrong way this much.