A review by teresatumminello
My Autobiography of Carson McCullers by Jenn Shapland

4.0

Many of us find it appealing to visit the homes of writers, soaking up the atmosphere, getting a sense of the way they wrote, through their things. Shapland, an archivist, relates what she did and how she felt during her stay at McCullers’ house/museum in Columbus, Georgia, in preparation for writing this book. And even though I spent just one night in an apartment above the Scott and Zelda Fitzgerald Museum in Montgomery, Alabama, I understood (though while reading of McCullers’s home, I was reminded of Eudora Welty’s). After I thought of the Fitzgerald house, I came upon Shapland’s mention of visiting it once and her being disappointed because she thought it was Zelda’s childhood home and expected much more Zelda than she got. (My experience was different in that I felt Zelda was revealed to me there.) Shapland mentions that visit because growing up Zelda was the person she felt connected to until she “met” Carson (as she always refers to her).

Though I’ve read most of McCullers’s works, I didn’t know much of her personal life beyond what I gleaned from her fiction and the biographical emphasis on her two marriages to the same man. I’ve never been able to satisfactorily reconcile those two elements and after reading this, I now know why. McCullers didn’t closet herself, especially not in her later years, but apparently her official and unofficial biographers did.*

This isn’t a biography of McCullers. It’s Shapland’s memoir (see the title, though it should be subtitled A Memoir as other editions are) of how her affinity to McCullers grew, and how she herself became self-aware through the exploration of material in the archives where she worked. Her discovery of McCullers’ therapy transcripts, which McCullers hoped to shape into an autobiography before her untimely death, is instrumental to her insights. Some of McCullers’ clothes are in the archives and Shapland relates to those as well, understanding through them that feeling of “not masculine; not feminine, but a both that becomes other.”

The chapters are short and punchy, their titles meaningful. Judging by my highlights, my favorite chapter was ‘The High Line’ with its attempt to get a (historical) grip on the 2016 election. While reading this book, I was reminded of other memoir/genre-blending works I’ve read in recent years, especially [a:Carmen Maria Machado|6860265|Carmen Maria Machado|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1461618720p2/6860265.jpg]’s [b:In the Dream House|43317482|In the Dream House|Carmen Maria Machado|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1547869259l/43317482._SX50_.jpg|65787792].

*(See message 9 below for a further explanation.)