OK I was torn on how to rate this one. It was a 4 star for me right up until the climax of the battle when i HATED what happened. But even with that it was too good a story not to give it 4 stars but honestly Christina -how could you?? On the romance front I am a JB fan but was happy to have Maddy with Gabriel because she loves him and hasn't wavered from that and she is such a likeable and kick ass heroine I want her to get the guy she loves. Bad Bad Christina - you better have that next book out soon.