A review by biscuitcrux
Anne of the Island by L.M. Montgomery

4.0

In this book, Anne is 18-21 and going to college. She meets a new friend with the same name as the 51st mayor of Phoenix, Phil Gordon. And she receives and turns down four separate proposals of marriage! One from her friend Jane's brother who she barely knows, one from a dude she's barely spoken to ever, one from the guy she actually ends up marrying later, and one from a guy she dated for two years but realized she didn't want to spend her life with. That's my girl, Anne, love 'em (or barely notice 'em) and leave 'em!

After reading three of these books, I am definitely in the camp that Anne could be queer. There is WAY more space devoted to her intense feelings for Diana Barry than any other relationship, and the stuff about Gilbert is always tucked away in the last chapter. I'm not saying she's definitely a lesbian, but one could certainly read it that way. When I played Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney for the first time, I was not expecting all the gay subtext in that game (and I loved it!), but it takes neither a genius nor an obsessive Yaoi fangirl to notice it. I think I would have noticed it in this book, even if I hadn't been primed by reading an article about the queer content first.

It's pretty fun seeing Anne as an adult getting to go around doing what she wants. These stories are all very sweet and I definitely plan on reading more of them.