A review by meghan_readsbooks
The Co-op by Tarah DeWitt

4.0

Thank you St Martins for the review copy!
TLDR: I really appreciated and had fun with this read, all kinds of favorite romance themes, emotional (in a good way), banter and second chance...., and no miscommunication!!!

Tarah DeWitt’s The Co-Op is an absolute delight for lovers of second-chance romance. The story of LaRynn and Deacon is one of growth, love, and finding beauty in imperfection. Both characters, shaped by troubled childhoods and feelings of inadequacy, face their pasts head-on as they work together to renovate a shared property. The symbolism of the dilapidated house, mirroring their broken relationship and individual struggles, is powerful and touching. Watching them repair the home as they rebuild trust and rediscover each other’s strengths is both heartwarming and profound. DeWitt’s writing is effortless, blending humor, heartfelt moments, and character depth seamlessly.

The story’s standout elements include its rich banter, emotional storytelling, and the protagonists' layered complexity. LaRynn’s sharp exterior and hidden vulnerability make her incredibly relatable, while Deacon’s unexpected depth adds to the chemistry between them. Their dynamic is full of tension, humor, and genuine affection, avoiding clichéd miscommunication tropes and instead showcasing open dialogue that brings authenticity to their connection. The dual timelines enrich the narrative, making the journey back to each other feel earned. With DeWitt’s signature blend of romance, comedy, and exploration of grief and resilience, this book is a testament to love’s healing power. Expect laughter, heartfelt sighs, and the occasional tear—The Co-Op is a must-read that leaves you wishing for more.