Scan barcode
A review by therivingtonreader
A Little Life by Hanya Yanagihara
3.0
I have so many conflicting thoughts about this book, so I'm just listing good vs. bad.
The good:
- the characters are easy to love and connect with, especially Willem, Harold, and Julia
- the majority of this book was interesting and easy to follow
- the writing is so beautiful. There are many valuable lessons and incredible quotes to get from this story. Some of my favorites are:
• “He experienced the
singular pleasure of
watching people he loved
fall in love with other people
he loved.”
• “But what was happiness
but an extravagance, an
impossible state to
maintain, partly because it
was so difficult to
articulate?”
• “Fairness is for happy
people, for people who have
been lucky enough to have
lived a life defined more by
certainties than by
ambiguities.
Right and wrong, however,
are for—well, not unhappy
people, maybe, but scarred
people; scared people.”
The bad:
- much of the trauma that Jude experienced borders on misery porn
- the traumatic events began to be repetitive, and made the middle of the book drag
- at times it felt like the author dreamt up the most horrific shit that could ever happen to a person and threw it in the book
- there are multiple detailed pages of a child being groomed and sexually abused
- I would not feel comfortable recommending this to someone
Overall, I don't regret reading this. There were certainly good parts about it and things I will take away from it. But I could've done without most of the explicit things that happened to Jude. We could've understood that Jude was clearly mentally/physically ill without all of that.
The good:
- the characters are easy to love and connect with, especially Willem, Harold, and Julia
- the majority of this book was interesting and easy to follow
- the writing is so beautiful. There are many valuable lessons and incredible quotes to get from this story. Some of my favorites are:
• “He experienced the
singular pleasure of
watching people he loved
fall in love with other people
he loved.”
• “But what was happiness
but an extravagance, an
impossible state to
maintain, partly because it
was so difficult to
articulate?”
• “Fairness is for happy
people, for people who have
been lucky enough to have
lived a life defined more by
certainties than by
ambiguities.
Right and wrong, however,
are for—well, not unhappy
people, maybe, but scarred
people; scared people.”
The bad:
- much of the trauma that Jude experienced borders on misery porn
- the traumatic events began to be repetitive, and made the middle of the book drag
- at times it felt like the author dreamt up the most horrific shit that could ever happen to a person and threw it in the book
- I would not feel comfortable recommending this to someone
Overall, I don't regret reading this. There were certainly good parts about it and things I will take away from it. But I could've done without most of the explicit things that happened to Jude. We could've understood that Jude was clearly mentally/physically ill without all of that.