This was a little too similar to Caraval at times but because I love Caraval so much I was willing to keep going. Overall I liked the premise but some of the trials felt a little too simple. The main character was a little annoying at times - too headstrong and not willing to ask for help even when it was the common sense thing to do. I liked the twist at the end but it wasn't surprising. The book was distinct enough Caraval from by the end and I'm intrigued enough to keep reading the series.