"Women & Children" by Tony Birch delves into the haunting echoes of silence surrounding past traumas, painting a vivid picture of working-class Melbourne in the 1960s. Through the eyes of young Joe Cluny, Birch navigates the complexities of familial secrets and the pervasive violence against women.

While the novel's exploration of these themes is commendable, its narrative structure feels somewhat formulaic, and the dialogue occasionally rings unnaturally. Despite this, Birch's prose remains poignant, sensitively capturing the innocence of youth and the harsh realities of adulthood. However, some characters, such as Joe's mother, Marion and Aunt Oona, feel underdeveloped, falling into familiar tropes.

Birch's portrayal of the Catholic Church's complicity in the face of domestic violence adds depth to the narrative. Yet, the plot progression may feel predictable and an abrupt ending that borders on unbelievable. Nevertheless, Birch's refusal to shy away from uncomfortable truths and his skilful avoidance of heavy-handed metaphors elevate "Women & Children" into a compelling, if flawed, exploration of resilience and the enduring power of storytelling.

⭐ ⭐ ⭐