Although not quite as enjoyable as the Count of Monte Cristo this book was still well written with creative and intriguing characters. The contrast between the brother's characters is beautifully handled and the dilemma of the Musketeers' once they discover the prisoner's identity is heart-wrenching. Admittedly it does help if you have read the previous novels as these explain the bonds between the men and their loyalty to their country although I don't think it is absolutely necessary as long as you have a vague awareness of the Musketeers and what they stand.

Upon reading this again I did enjoy it a bit more but it still isn't quite as enjoyable as some of Dumas' other works. I can't quite put my finger on why as it has everything including sibling rivalry, betrayal and redemption, a few sword fights, and of course some wonderful witty moments from the musketeers.