Scan barcode
A review by suburbanfoxes
The Critic as Artist by Oscar Wilde
challenging
informative
4.0
I can't say in earnest that I understood everything in this essay. I am truly not smart enough to understand many of the references that Wilde makes, which did make this quite dense and difficult to read at times. However, as for the ideas that I do understand, I agree with some but not others. Regardless of that, though, there are certainly thought-provoking ideas here, along with humor and clever word play, with the overall whole feeling both sincere and insincere at the same time. And as a classical pianist, I had fun with the pretentious dialogue about art (especially with the numerous references to classical music).
“It is sometimes said that the tragedy of an artist’s life is that he cannot realize his ideal. But the true tragedy that dogs the steps of most artists is that they realize their ideal too absolutely. For, when the ideal is realized, it is robbed of its wonder and its mystery, and becomes simply a new starting-point for an ideal that is other than itself. This is the reason why music is the perfect type of art. Music can never reveal its ultimate secret.” (p 76)