T. Kingfisher creates memorable, quirky characters. Galen and Piper have distinct personalities, their chemistry is engaging, and they are easy to describe. Secondary characters, like the supporting clergy and even minor figures, are fleshed out and contribute meaningfully to the narrative. The characters’ motivations were clear, and their struggles resonated with me emotionally, making it easy to care about what happens to them.

The world-building is solid, with vivid descriptions that balance whimsical and dark tones. I could picture the gothic atmosphere, the interplay of the divine and mundane, and the oddities of the magical world. However, not all scenes had the same level of energy or immersion, and some quieter moments felt less atmospheric than I would have liked.

T. Kingfisher’s writing is accessible, humorous, and poignant. The prose feels effortless, with a conversational tone that doesn’t detract from the emotional beats or world-building. Dialogue is snappy and engaging, fitting seamlessly into the narration. I enjoyed the blend of humor and heartfelt moments, which left me eager for more of her work.

The plot is well-paced, avoiding major lulls or unnecessary complexity. While it delivers satisfying twists and builds intrigue effectively, it didn’t feel particularly groundbreaking. The central mystery and romantic subplot were interwoven neatly, and the resolution was rewarding, but the overall story didn’t surprise me in a way that set it apart from others in the genre.

The book is engaging, balancing lighthearted romance with darker mystery elements. The interplay between the protagonists and the looming danger kept me interested. I wanted to keep reading to unravel both the plot and the characters’ relationships, though there were moments where the tension dipped slightly.

The characters’ actions align with their personalities and motivations, and the rules of the world are consistently followed. Relationships—romantic, platonic, and antagonistic—are well-developed and felt natural rather than forced. The magical elements and world-building are clear and consistent, but I occasionally felt that more depth could have been added to the setting or backstory.

The blend of humor, mystery, and romance created an enjoyable reading experience for me. T. Kingfisher’s unique voice made the book stand out, and although it wasn’t the most profound or life-changing story, it delivered on its promises and left me satisfied.