This is a very interresting book. I loce the idea of picking the best days to remember from your life. Yet there are bad days as we learn at the end. Though i don't think it is fair to punish someone that bands the rules. 

He was put into that position to do so and a good men will try to help in any way he can. So i think the ending is kina sad. I know they reïncarnatie and stuff but still. I did not like the reason why his memories were take.