Set against the backdrop of a small Midwestern town, the story kicks off with the mysterious disappearance of two paperboys separated by a couple of years. The latest one spirals into a heartbreaking chain of events that changes everything for the community. Inspired by the real-life, still unsolved Des Moines Register paperboy kidnappings from the early '80s, this book really makes you reflect on how innocent and trusting kids were back then.

The early '80s felt like a bubble where bad things didn’t happen to kids—if something went wrong, it was always assumed to be the work of a stranger. But The Monsters We Make dives deep into the unsettling reality of how easy it is for children to fall victim to someone they know, and my reaction to this story lingered long after I finished the book.

What I loved most was the captivating, slow burn storytelling. The perspectives of Sammy, Crystal, and Officer Dale Goodkind are beautifully woven together, each character bringing their own struggles and secrets into the mix. Their individual stories add so much depth to the the book, making it even more compelling. Mirroring real life, the story doesn’t have a nicely wrapped up ending. 

Overall, this book not only keeps you on the edge of your seat but also leaves a lasting impact, reminding us of the real-life tragedy that inspired it. If you’re looking for a haunting, thought-provoking read that will stick with you, The Monsters We Make is definitely worth picking up!