I liked the witch and magic portion of this book but there were so many moments where I rolled my eyes and said, "Really?" I think there is a decent plot and alright characters but it feels unpolished. So many ideas that are hardly tied together. It feels like someone made a storyboard and started using too much red yarn without caring how it would be written out and blindly connecting ideas and hoping for the best. I don't think I'll continue this series, but good luck to Willow I guess