I liked it but found Cheyenee too be too wishy washy for me and all. Also her friends were very judgmental just like she was about Dylan. I liked dylan okay , but the one I liked the most was Joe. Why all of a sudden when he is interested, isn't she interested anymore. Plus Presley seemed like a wash out to me but i liked her character. It's unrealistic to think that when you are on a cruise you can reach someone easily. I felt like I would have liked to learn more about Cheynne's past. I can't wait for Joe,Presley and Sophia's story. It was ridiculous how involved her friends were in her love life. I liked how soft hearted Dylan was and his relationship with his brothers and how he knew how the town felt about him. The character of Presley is why I give this book 4 stars, plus Aaron and the rehab issues. What right do her friends have to stage an intervention? One thing I liked about the book was how much respect Joe and Dylan had for her each other, and how Eve was ready to step aside.