I would give this book like 3.9 stars. I liked the book, it just made me cringe so much. I had to put the book down several times while reading just because of how much obsessive shit she did at an age where she should have known better. Honestly tho like she is so stupid to think that Davis gave her the letter, like are you kidding me bro, why would Davis give Carl a letter. Clearly Carl hates Davis and doesn’t want you around him. She is so stupid. Davis was 100% the better character, and he was so sweet and caring. He apologized a lot for what he said, which was sweet. Although in my opinion she should have apologized for stalking him and just being a creepy teenager, and honestly everything Gavin said was right, and I loved when David said all those things to her, because she never truly understood that what she did was borderline creepy and objective. Not like she got the hint after tho, still chalked it up to being a teenager. I really liked the epilogue, I’m really happy to know that his brother didn’t blame him and that it was his own fault. Because seriously it was Timothy’s own fault, like he was driving.