Even though Maggie and her husband have been together since they were teens, they find themselves divorcing less than two years after their wedding. Although she pretends everything is fine, Maggie is a hot mess. With observant sarcasm, Heisey narrates Maggie's self-destruction thoughts and cringeworthy choices as she painfully learns to take care of herself.

Although Heisey's clever observations made me laugh at times, Really, Good Actually wasn't really that good. As a protagonist, Maggie is hard to love; she's an over-the-top hot mess who has no concept of how the world actually works. Her constant poor decision-making gets a bit old and the plot rambled so much that I didn't even notice when my audiobook skipped a chapter or two in the middle. The only saving grace was Heisey's witty writing and hilarious one-liners.