I didn't like the ending, and that’s what led to this book being a 4-stars for me.

Despite all of what the Prophet has done to her and her family, Immauelle chooses to spare. Like huh? This man literally took advantage of her best friend and got her pregnant which led to her death. Did I mention he also killed her parents? This man does not deserve mercy. There’s no reason to keep this man alive.

At first, I felt bad for the witches, but I realized they're no better than the people of Bethel. They turned on Immauelle the second after she didn't comply with them and

and even killed her grandfather.

They took advantage of Miriam, Immauelle's mother, when she was at her lowest and manipulated her.

Overall, I liked this book but I don't think it needs a second book.