Maybe a 3.5.

I feel very strangely about this book. I found it both horribly boring and completely engaging at the same time. I generally like a lot of plot and a fast paced novel, but this book was the complete opposite. Much more character building and a slower, less intense plot.

I hated Danny and Rosemary, though I suppose I was supposed to. I felt bad for both Ria and Bernadette for being in love with such an asshole. I didn't have that much sympathy for Rosemary though. I felt sympathy for both Mona and Polly for the same reasons regarding Barney.

Towards the end I thought it was building up to Jack killing Gertie and I'm so glad that didn't happen.

I'm also glad that Ria didn't end up with Danny again. I liked the idea of Andy but that wouldn't have been incredibly realistic and I like the prospect of Colm and I'm happy that it ended on an ambiguous note in that regard. Also Greg surprising Marilyn in Ireland was a really touching point in the novel and I was happy that they were able to work through Dale's death and keep their marriage in tact.