Threadneedle kicks off in a pretty grim setting, and I’ll admit, I initially wondered if it could even be considered cozy fantasy. I mean, magic is feared and witches are literally dangling from Big Ben. Plus the initial darkness, especially around the character of Anna’s aunt and the binders, who are undeniably cruel and unlikable, casted a big shadow over the story. Hardly the warm, fuzzy vibes I was expecting. However, when the Queen of fantasy, aka Robin Hobb, herself gives it five stars, you buckle up and keep reading.

Once the story sheds some of its darkness, about the time we enter the high school, we’re suddenly, dealing with schoolgirl dramas: infatuations, bullying, gossip, friendship conflicts, and the all too familiar teenage angst. The high school scenes are so impressively realistic, I almost felt like a teenager myself. Next to it, the way how self discovery is portrayed among the characters is both relatable and touching. It’s the stronger point of this novel, the character-driven plot with is magical atmosphere making an unique blend of magical elements combined with the very real struggles of teenage life.

That said, these characters are so well crafted. One of my favorite characters is Effie. She sweeps in like a badass and it’s her confident presence that makes this into a core found family dynamic. Then there’s Selene, who’s got that irresistible free spirited vibe, and Rowan’s mom, who’s basically giving us a wink to a certain red headed witchy mother we all know (but won’t mention for obvious reasons).

The magic system, rooted in witchcraft and passed through family lines, is also a highlight, with the rich lore and history of the binders, short stories, riddles, and spells adding depth to the world. The novels, almost autumnal, cozy moments, particularly outside of Anna’s home, were a beautiful contrast from the heavier parts of the story.

By the end, this book totally wrecked me. It had me cringing at cruelty, swooning over friendships, feeling all kinds of fluttery excitement and had me feeling both cozy and stressed at the same time. Though it took me a little while to fully engage with the story, once I connected with Anna, her friends, the magic, the high school drama and the mystery at the heart of it all, I was hooked. It even reminded me of the feelings I had when I first read that other magical series we don’t talk about.

So, huge thanks to @ginaluciareads for the recommendation, it’s easily become a new favorite. So next time I know, if Hobb says it’s worth it, you know you’re in for something special!