**Thank you NetGalley and RHCBEducators/Random House Children’s- Delacorte Pree for this ARC! All thoughts and opinions are my own.**
Posted to: NetGalley and The StoryGraph 

Posted on: 26 November 2024

I kind of requested this book on a whim after seeing that we are birthday twins (hello other Dec 10 babies <3). The premise of it seemed interesting and I thought it fell into all the right boxes for some of my favorite books, so I said why not and requested it!

Little did I know that I would find a heart and home within the pages.

I usually like to start off my book reviews with things that I didn’t like all too much in the book, but there was very little of that here. I get what some people disliked about the language used. In the first chapter, we get the infamous “not today, satan!” quote that I found a little funnily out of place, but not terribly bad? There’s a lot more instances of “oh la la la la la la” (I’m not exaggerating at how many ‘la’s’ either) that were more annoyingly overused, but even then it wasn’t enough to overpower the rest of the story. Besides that, I personally don’t think the language used sucks you out of the story too much. That’s just my personal opinion though!

Next on the list- characters. There’s a good mix of characters at play in this story. We, of course, have the main duo mentioned in the summary- Joséphine and Clara. We get plenty of villagers too, some soldiers (vaguely anyways) and some rich men too far from danger to realize its true effect. Because of all the moving pieces needed to help nudge the story and its central theme along, I think the length didn’t give enough time to flesh out the smaller notes. Yes, we’re given reasons to hate the monsters living inside the houses, but it’s surface level. We see girls with bruises who flinch away from men or girls who do what they need to get out of their homes. And yes, I did hate the men and the boys and the priest who needed to get more than just bit, but if the novel was longer, the dislike could’ve been sown deeper.

I think that’s my real complaint here, I just wanted this novel to be a little longer. I loved the angry main character who yearned to feel beloved and needed. I loved the gentle secondary character who loved all the sharp bits and held a fire of her own in her chest. I loved the cast of girls we follow that support each other, that learn to lean on each other and break their silence. I think I just wanted to see more of them, especially with the ending that we are given (I got chills reading that epilogue at the gym, truly this book has a piece of my heart) 

‘We Are the Beasts’ spoke to the anger in me. It reminded me that the anger isn’t /just/ in me, but in all of us, in different ways. This book is for the fiery, feral voices with teeth sharp enough to rip. This book is also for the quieter, careful voices with hands to mend but hearts that burn. I think this book fed the same fire in me that reading Clytemnestra’s story did- and I wholly support all the women’s wrongs that might have transpired during the first page up to the last of this novel.

CW: blood, abuse, mention of child death and allusions to how it happened/what happened to the body, murder, passing mentions of torture and sexual harassment where you can assume what the intentions were but it’s not exactly written out word for word.