Still garbage. Maybe worse than the first one…but who knows?! The underage relationships are gross. The fat shaming is gross. The parents reactions to literally everything (but especially adult men having sex with their teenage daughters while dating their adult daughters) is gross. 

Also, all the girls make wildly outrageous conclusions about who A is with basically no proof or reasoning. Toby is not as creepy in the books as they make him seem in the show and all 4 of them being so convinced he’s A is ridiculous. These books are so dumb and I do not recommend.