Honestly my rating is more for the series then for this particular novella. I always was a fan of Marley and Carter, and was hoping to really get a good look into their story. But, I don't think we got that great of a look into their love story, and how they felt about each other, and most importantly why they felt this way about one another. I mean they gave up everything to be together, and I still after reading this don't know why. But it was really nice to visit the world of America, I just love that girl!