While I usually have a low tolerance for teenage angst, Faith's angst was actually justified and Hardinge was so eloquent in expressing the swirl of emotions she was feeling.

The story had me on tenterhooks - I wasn't sure where it was all going and revelled in its unfurling mystery. I didn't want it to end, but it was the perfect place to conclude the story. I actually rolled around on the floor exclaiming "what a good book! Ah!!" when I was finished (caveat: I was already on the floor).

Riddell's illustrations are flawless (as usual) - such a great touch to an already amazing book. Fiercely happy I bought the hardback.

Spoiler

I loved the sweet surprise of finding out about Miss Hunter and Mrs Vellet. It made so much sense in hindsight!