I chose this book for one of my book of the month boxes in the spring. I was super excited about it because I love Historical Fiction and this sounded particularly interesting. Unfortunately, after reading it, I found it a bit underwhelming. The plot was a bit convoluted, the characters weren't entirely likeable or relatable, and this was less historical and much more fictional.

Let's start with the plot. I think the most basic part of the concept for the plot is really cool and had a lot of potential. A Frick family heirloom of immense value goes missing and someone is wrongfully accused. For me, where this fell apart is that it took over half the book to get to this particular point and the story seems, up until that point, more invested in the lives of two women...the personal assistant to the Frick daughter and a random model from the UK decades later. Each has their own plot line and it's not until the very end that they start to tie together. In my opinion, the plot that takes place decades later was unrealistic and detracted from the story. 

The characters were also a bit difficult for me. I am under the impression that we aren't supposed to like most of the Frick family and that's fine. Purposefully unlikeable characters are fine. That said, the two main characters...Lillian, the personal assistant and Veronica, the English model were super hard for me to relate to as well. I thought both had great potential, it just wasn't explored. Their storylines could've been moving and deep, but I felt like they were sort of created as an afterthought to the rest of the plot. 

Additionally, this really is more of a fiction than a historical fiction. Yes, the Fricks were a real family and the location is a real location. Other than that, it's almost entirely made up. I guess when I read a historical fiction, I have the expectation that the story will be grounded in some of the actual history. Had the plot and characterization been more compelling, perhaps I would've noticed this less or been less bothered by it.

All in all, this was a middle of the line historical fiction for me. It had lots of potential, but ultimately did not deliver. It's not to say that it's not worth a read, but just temper your expectations going into it.