beejai's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Nigel Cliff presents a new look on the beginnings of the age of discovery with a particular emphasis on the journeys of Vasco da Gama. He begins with an overview of the reconquista and the creation of Portugal and then focus on the religious fervor of Christian vs Muslim as the primary motivator that spurred Europe into global dominance.
While his history is excellent, well researched and yet easily readable, I believe he has placed far too much emphasis on the religious factor. The traditional (and I believe correct view) was that Portugal and Spain desired to find the source for the spice trade rather than continue to be dependent on the Istanbul/Egypt/Venice monopoly. Religion was certainly a motivator on both sides for many of the local conflicts, misunderstandings, and even atrocities that occurred on both sides. However this was mainly an economic conflict that forever shifted the balance of power away from the Eastern Mediterranean center since Constantine towards Western Europe.
While the book is definitely worth reading there is not nearly enough validity to convince any unbiased viewer of Cliff's primary premise that Portugal was embarking on a "Crusade".

gopalms's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This is a wonderful book from an Indian history point of view. Especially for most of us who learnt history in our textbooks which are too basic and do not get the bigger picture nor the details of how our history played out in reality.

If you want to know more about what happened in Calicut you should follow this book up with a visit to a blog called Historical Alleys. You can google and find it. It has stories of many of the major and minor playerson the Indian coast during the Portuguese and Dutch days.

laurafox's review

Go to review page

3.0

For some reason, this book just didn't hold my interest like I thought it would. (It's telling that I stopped reading at certain points so that I could start and finish other books.) I was also bugged by the sweeping story-telling that seemed to have less in the way of supporting source material. The story about da Vinci dying in the arms of Francis I, for example -- which is told in the Epilogue -- is an apocryphal (and almost certainly fictional) story lifted whole-cloth from Vasari.