Reviews

覆面系ノイズ 4 by Ryōko Fukuyama

toriwatson's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional funny lighthearted fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.25

silver_star08's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Anontmous Noise, Vol. 4

Nino, Yuzu, & the gang are getting ready to put out In No Hurry's debut album. They are also signed to perform at a music festival.

But Momo & his band are about to do the same.

elanna_g's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

It was nice to get the backstory of how the band started, but there was much too less main story progression in this volume. I was a bit bored at times, but I'm really looking forward at what's to come.

ruthsic's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

I think I have reached the point where I can say: Too MUCH Angst, OMG. So, after Yuzu suddenly kissed Nino (why would you even do that, dude) and she stops talking to him, he scrambles for a way to make it right. After much apologizing and assuring her it wasn't because he was in love with her, they get back together as friends. Meanwhile, Nino has been re-evaluating what makes her singing powerful - her past live performances for the band were done when she was emotionally stressed, but they still turning out good doesn't mean it will always be so. So, she is trying to figure out how to bring that same raw power to her singing in normal circumstances, while also side-eyeing the guitar she got from Momo. A major storyline in this book was the past of In No Hurry - as in, how they were formed, and how Nino was a catalyst for it. I am still, however, very interested in why Yuzu's mom is such a hardass towards him about music.

The romance front is quite messy, and shows no sign of untangling the web of unrequited love. We have Haruyoshi in love with Miou in love with Yuzu in love with Nino, who is in love with Momo, and supposedly Momo has a girlfriend, who I really hope is not that Tsukika (mostly because she definitely isn't a high school girl and he is 15). Then comes the fact that Momo and Yuzu are being petty AF about 'ownership' of Nino's voice; both of them think the other is manipulating to steal her away from him, as if she has no agency in this matter. Sure, teens can be messy and impulsive, but even their childhood selves would be side-eyeing them right now. Look, the girl is an airhead most of the time, but she sorta knows what she wants, okay? The slight relief in this messiness comes in the fact that we see Nino interact a bit more with Miou and more importantly, Haruyoshi; now we only need a heart-to-heart with Kuro, as it seems they only interact with her through Yuzu. There was also a nice bit of band solidarity as they decide how to keep the Alice image.

Overall, this volume is full of angst, but also has some backstory to make up for it.