Beautiful drawings- everyone looks unique and a wide range of ethnicities even though this world sees being a witch is one thing and mortal another. I also like how the ending tied up nicely. A book for those who like witches, spells, friendship and found family. My only thing is

why did Ms Paxton/Lilith Younwity give Abby a “healing” pouch with lilies of the valley? Was she trying to get her to find Noreen and eventually Karla?

This has truly gorgeous art and I loved the diversity of characters. Unfortunately, everything outside of the art fell flat for me. The story is underdeveloped and none of the characters have a personality. 

The strongest part of this book was its sense of place and atmosphere. The magical academy setting bleeds through on every page. It felt fully realised, with lesson details, a cast of teachers, and a host of different spaces shown such as classrooms (which all had a unique look), the library, dorm rooms, gardens etc. As well as this the plot is structured around the school celebration of Samhain. So when I say this book is set in a magical academy it is SET in a magical academy. The colours and lighting, in addition to the castle/manor-like feel of the academy, made for a spooky, dark academia atmosphere. 

The mystery plot was perfectly fine considering this was a YA graphic novel. It kept me interested in picking the book up again and again, especially given it had a cold/historical case component.

The art was also great. I liked the fine lines and the narrowness of the illustrations, although I will say that the panel placement in trying to keep things fresh and unique all the time was ironically sometimes repetitive. 

The characters were definitely the weakest part of this book. The MC was very Mary-Sue to me. I think exploring the foundling aspect more, which was underutilised all round, could have given her more dimension. Goldie and Violet were compelling enough side characters, but Enver needed more work; outside of being friends with Noreen I didn't really know who they were.