Reviews

Giants Beware! by John Novak, Rafael Rosado, Matthew Schenk, Jorge Aguirre

radlibrarian's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Cringed at some of the dialogue about the father in a wheelchair, but ended up liking this much more in the end.

ms_librarian_reads's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Sosado’s art that Booklist praises as both “manga-inspired” and having “distinctive characteristics of Charles Schulz” along with Aguirre’s classic storyline of a hero on a quest, combine in fairy tale that School Library Journal calls “ a fine balance between being action-and friendship-driven”. Claudette, who Publisher’s Weekly calls “delightfully spunky” fights evil with swordplay, and aspiring princess, Marie uses cleverness. Claudette’s brother, Gaston dreams of becoming a pastry chef/swordsmith. Children, therefore, will identify with the characters regardless of their gender and how they choose to express it. Jokes both low (Claudette owes some narrow escapes to the stench of her feet), high (Marie remarks that the Forest of Death could use a new publicist) and in between, will appeal to readers of various ages. Fantasy fans as well as voracious graphic novel readers aged eight and up will all find something to enjoy, although an unexplained backstory may leave them craving a sequel.

jiden's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Cute, though not as empowering as I was hoping from a female-centric giant slayer story. (Let's just say I knew without having to check that the writer are artist were both males.)

remkosiak's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Grades 3-5

Claudette, a spunky medieval girl with her heart set on giant-slaying, encounters some difficulty doing so because she is a girl. Accompanied by her cowardly brother, Gaston, and Marie, Claudette's polar opposite, determined Claudette sets out to slay a giant. Giants beware? More like anyone-who-crosses-the-main-character-Claudette Beware!

An action-packed graphic novel for adventure-lovers, Giants Beware! introduces a powerful main character and expertly blends comedy with fantasy.

mlhahn's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Everything everyone else has said about how great this book is. But what I'm REALLY looking forward to is having a discussion with kids about the ending. That last page threw me for a loop.

Do you think this is too long to read aloud with the document camera?

Summer 2012 #bookaday #18

robbishreads's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

About the fare of a typical Saturday morning cartoon from back in the day. Somehow, stretching it into a full length graphic novel really, really works for it though. I think maybe the lack of annoying voice actors and time to polish the jokes so they're not stupid really elevates it. There's always something charming about the old trope where the adults are idiots and the kids just seem to get it-though here they're kind of idiots too, but you love them anyway.

thereadingcountess's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Giants Beware will surely be a winner with its intended audience. A Bluebonnet listed book for 2013-2014 in Texas, I picked this one up in order to book talk it to my students. I read it. I book talked it to encourage them to read the minimum five titles by January in order to vote for their favorite Bluebonnet. But would I give it two thumbs up? No.

booktothepointe's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Super cute middle grade graphic novel. Unlikely group of village kids goes on a quest to kill a giant who has scared the town for years. Claudette is a rough and tumble girl who cares for her friends and is the leader of her crew. Her little brother and girly friend who longs to be a princess accompany her on the quest to vanquish the giant. Shenanigans ensue and they return to the town victorious!

lazofiaczyta's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Chyba dałam sobie challenge polegający na przeczytaniu wszystkich komiksów jakie mam w pracy XD Nie żebym miała ich jakoś dużo, ale trochę jest. Dzięki temu odkryłam całkiem fajną serię przygodową z bohaterką, która na początku wzięłam za chłopaka, chyba przez jej krótkie włosy. Jeśli ktoś lubi Hildę to jak najbardziej polecam sięgnięcie po serię z Claudette. Obie dziewczyny są nieustraszonymi poszukiwaczkami przygód, wymykającymi się ustalonym zasadom i normom, tutaj głównie dobrego wychowania i tego co wypada a co nie dziewczynkom. No i mają oczywiście oddanych towarzyszy przygód. Lekkie, wciągające, w sam raz na lato.

laurenofsunday's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Claudette is OBSESSED with killing the giant that use to terrorize her town. Once she loops her friend, Marie, and her brother, Gaston, into the adventure, they set out for Giant Mountain. Along the way they run into some unforeseen bumps, but find that the monsters that lurk outside of the wall may not be as horrid as their tales make them out to be.