Take a photo of a barcode or cover
Reviews
Weathering: The Extraordinary Stress of Ordinary Life in an Unjust Society by Arline T. Geronimus
priyahc's review
emotional
hopeful
informative
reflective
slow-paced
3.5
This book was super informative from a scientific and anecdotal perspective. Unfortunately, I felt there was a missed opportunity for a direct, organized critique of the specific policies and institutions that are still weathering us.
There was a lot of talk about Trump’s racist language and the 20th- and 21st-century policies that brought us to this moment. There was also a lot of talk, as another reader mentioned, about individual and classroom-sized approaches to mitigating weathering on a small scale. As for a larger scale, there were some acknowledgements of car-dependency, mass incarceration, mass deportations, the inaccessibility of healthcare, and more. Unlike the small-scale solutions, however, larger-scale solutions were scattered throughout the book and not as decisive.
Perhaps as a researcher, Dr. Geronimus is less involved in making policy recommendations and instead just advises policymakers? But based on her research findings, I was waiting for her to suggest Medicare for all, police/prison/ICE abolition, student loan forgiveness, etc. as solutions to structural racism across the US. There was such a specific, detailed list of suggestions on making a small impact; meanwhile, the suggestions for a large impact were making healthcare more accessible in rural communities and being vigilant about Biden’s funding allocations, along with the concept of “revolution.”
I feel the book could have been supplemented with a foreword or conclusion written by someone who’s comfortable talking about what a “revolution” — or at least policies that aim to dismantle oppressive institutions — would actually entail.
Also, whoever said male OB/GYNs didn’t deserve the smoke she gave them — lol, yes they did.
There was a lot of talk about Trump’s racist language and the 20th- and 21st-century policies that brought us to this moment. There was also a lot of talk, as another reader mentioned, about individual and classroom-sized approaches to mitigating weathering on a small scale. As for a larger scale, there were some acknowledgements of car-dependency, mass incarceration, mass deportations, the inaccessibility of healthcare, and more. Unlike the small-scale solutions, however, larger-scale solutions were scattered throughout the book and not as decisive.
Perhaps as a researcher, Dr. Geronimus is less involved in making policy recommendations and instead just advises policymakers? But based on her research findings, I was waiting for her to suggest Medicare for all, police/prison/ICE abolition, student loan forgiveness, etc. as solutions to structural racism across the US. There was such a specific, detailed list of suggestions on making a small impact; meanwhile, the suggestions for a large impact were making healthcare more accessible in rural communities and being vigilant about Biden’s funding allocations, along with the concept of “revolution.”
I feel the book could have been supplemented with a foreword or conclusion written by someone who’s comfortable talking about what a “revolution” — or at least policies that aim to dismantle oppressive institutions — would actually entail.
Also, whoever said male OB/GYNs didn’t deserve the smoke she gave them — lol, yes they did.
ecorbitt's review against another edition
challenging
informative
reflective
tense
fast-paced
5.0
Pithy tone and well-articulate research - what more could you ask for? This should be read in ever MSW program- better yet, this should be read by anyone who claims to serve marginalized communities.
entcristy's review
3.0
Agree with the concept but needs more concrete data other than anecdotes. Unfair to demonize male OBGYNs.