Scan barcode
Reviews
The Resilience Myth: New Thinking on Grit, Strength, and Growth After Trauma by Soraya Chemaly
jarrahpenguin's review against another edition
4.0
There's a lot of great stuff in this well-timed book about our cultural narrative of "resilience" and "grit." Soraya Chemaly takes a broad look at many ways the idea of "resilience" shapes our lives, in short sub-sections, and integrating personal and cultural examples. One chapter looks at childhood trauma and how children are being taught the ideal of resilience, being praised for, for example, showing "grit" in going back to school after a school shooting. Another looks at how negativity is a normal part of life that is important not to suppress in many situations, and another examines how resilience narratives have been tied into workplace/capitalist culture and the prioritization of "productivity." Throughout, Chemaly examines the way the resilience myth reinforces toxic gender dynamics and places an uneven burden on folks from various marginalized backgrounds.
When I picked up the book I was looking for a deeper dive on the productivity/workplace aspects of resilience culture and found a lot of the content fairly high-level and familiar for me. But I appreciated the range of dynamics covered and Chemaly's accessible, heartfelt writing style. I would definitely recommend this book for people just coming to the realization that something is off when it comes to how our society glamorizes resilience.
When I picked up the book I was looking for a deeper dive on the productivity/workplace aspects of resilience culture and found a lot of the content fairly high-level and familiar for me. But I appreciated the range of dynamics covered and Chemaly's accessible, heartfelt writing style. I would definitely recommend this book for people just coming to the realization that something is off when it comes to how our society glamorizes resilience.
brogan7's review against another edition
challenging
hopeful
informative
reflective
medium-paced
5.0
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It's an unapologetic push back on the cult of thriving in our culture, you know the one where any adversity is meant to be met with positive thinking! And how "everything happens for a reason" and how you will personally rise above any challenge and be the better for it!
This book resinserts a justice-narrative to this toxic positivity, reminding readers that ignoring the social and oppressive roots of inequalities in favour of the supremacy of the individual does not make for a better society, it makes for unhappy individuals and a broken society.
If we see resilience as residing in communities as opposed to individuals, it reminds us not to look to the person who is suffering to solve their own problems, but to look to the supports both personal and structural that can make their lives, and therefore everyone's life, better. Consider the difference between a woman leaving an abusive relationship if she is meant to rise above this and see it as all her problem, to find new employment, to catch up on perhaps lacking education, to chart her own path, versus if she is meant to be supported in a circumstance that doesn't affect every woman but could affect any woman: how do we structurally support her to have the best odds of succeeding? How would we implement child care, education, and legal supports to help her do well?
I thought this book was very accessible and interesting, pertinent and hopeful.
I did think some references (to missiles being phallic, etc) were a bit odd.
But overall, this is a solid read and inspiring to call out the cult of resilience that is troublesome to women and historically oppressed groups whether due to race, sexual orientation, or belief, but also to people who happen to end up in a difficult circumstance such as illness, disability or family tragedy.
This book resinserts a justice-narrative to this toxic positivity, reminding readers that ignoring the social and oppressive roots of inequalities in favour of the supremacy of the individual does not make for a better society, it makes for unhappy individuals and a broken society.
If we see resilience as residing in communities as opposed to individuals, it reminds us not to look to the person who is suffering to solve their own problems, but to look to the supports both personal and structural that can make their lives, and therefore everyone's life, better. Consider the difference between a woman leaving an abusive relationship if she is meant to rise above this and see it as all her problem, to find new employment, to catch up on perhaps lacking education, to chart her own path, versus if she is meant to be supported in a circumstance that doesn't affect every woman but could affect any woman: how do we structurally support her to have the best odds of succeeding? How would we implement child care, education, and legal supports to help her do well?
I thought this book was very accessible and interesting, pertinent and hopeful.
I did think some references (to missiles being phallic, etc) were a bit odd.
But overall, this is a solid read and inspiring to call out the cult of resilience that is troublesome to women and historically oppressed groups whether due to race, sexual orientation, or belief, but also to people who happen to end up in a difficult circumstance such as illness, disability or family tragedy.
amandadtx's review against another edition
challenging
hopeful
informative
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
4.5
writerbeverly's review
5.0
4.5 stars. If you pick this up hoping it will give you *personal* tips on how to bounce back after trauma, this isn't that book. It IS a book about resilience and recovery as *communities.* Which, of course, benefit us as individuals.
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book via a Goodreads giveaway.
A fair amount of this book focuses on Bahamian communities' resilience following hurricanes. It's a broader look at trauma, and the myths (see: title) about how we each have to go it alone. Because, John Wayne movies to the contrary, no one is an island. We are all inter-dependent, and we recover better when we do it together. "Soldiering on" isn't something that works - even in the military, except for short periods of time. I will probably reread this one on a regular basis.
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book via a Goodreads giveaway.
A fair amount of this book focuses on Bahamian communities' resilience following hurricanes. It's a broader look at trauma, and the myths (see: title) about how we each have to go it alone. Because, John Wayne movies to the contrary, no one is an island. We are all inter-dependent, and we recover better when we do it together. "Soldiering on" isn't something that works - even in the military, except for short periods of time. I will probably reread this one on a regular basis.
forzasusan's review
5.0
This book hit me exactly when I needed it and it covers topics I've been talking about with friends for quite some time. The biggest take away is that when our culture refers to resilience -- it isn't talking about real resilience -- almost like the Princess Bride movie quote of "I do not think it means what you think it means..." (pardon me if the quote is not 100% accurate ). I needed this book and am grateful for it.
diagenesisofsteph's review
4.0
Oh my goodness, what a refreshing take on this topic! I don’t think I’ve ever heard a discussion on resilience like this. And it was so validating because it highlighted everything that’s always felt off about the advice of powering through things.
The Resilience Myth presents different schools of thoughts around resilience then points out what’s almost always missing from the mainstream message - interdependence.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for an ARC of The Resilience Myth! This is my honest review.
The Resilience Myth presents different schools of thoughts around resilience then points out what’s almost always missing from the mainstream message - interdependence.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for an ARC of The Resilience Myth! This is my honest review.