amysmithlinton's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Short essays from Ms. Jones on how and why she wrote as she did. Fan-girl time.

jeannemixon's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

this book should not be read all the way through at once, partly because it is composed of author's talks and interviews and so the same topics are covered in the same way and the new material has to be teased out over several chapters and partly because it makes you want to read her novels and stop reading about her novels. I have wanted to know more about Diana Wynne Jones' childhood for a long time since I learned that she lived near Beatrix Potter and discovered that Potter hated children. Her stories are so bizarre and fanciful I figured her life must have been as well and it was. A very enjoyable read about a fascinating woman.

vierran's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A must-read for any DWJ fan. Though there is a lot of repetition in her talks, etc., this volume offers a very good overall picture of her person and her views on writing, young adult fiction, and fantasy in general.

jlb1234's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

The speeches were repetitive, but set out in a way that helped me learn something new with each one as I progressed through the book.

That said, and SPOILER - the afterword in which her son that her life isn't as she said and suggests she made it all up is such a, well, a bummer. I feel this should have been mentioned in the introduction rather than doing what Diana absolutely hated - telling everyone it was all a dream at the end of the book.

kittrick's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Diana is so witty and insightful, the talks and essays in this book are such a joy to read. There is a bit of repetition due to the nature of the collection but that can certainly be forgiven. A must read for anyone who loves her work or for anyone wanting to write children's fiction.

fabulitas's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Many pieces in this book are about writing for children and the preconceptions about children literature. These topics are of no particular interest to me, but they were still a good read, and the bits where Wynne Jones goes into detail about storytelling are very perceptive and sharp. And there is a brilliant essay on Tolkien.

sarah_taleweaver's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

As a general rule, I don't read nonfiction- essays in particular- outside of school. However, this book came highly recommended by a friend, and is also by one of my favorite authors, so I decided I might as well get it out from the library. So I did, and it sat in my stack of to-be-read library books until my mother warned me that it was going to be due in a week and if I wanted to read it, I'd better do so soon.

So, I read it. And, to my (foolish) surprise, I loved it. In fact, I loved it so much that I nearly forgot to stop reading and actually write my own story- not the best situation when it's nearly the end of Camp NaNoWriMo (as far as my schedule was concerned) and I have a quarter of the book left to write in a very busy week. Thankfully, I managed, and I rather hope the flavor of Diana Wynne Jones's words crept into what I wrote in between reading her essays.

The reason I left this book sit so long is that whenever I hear "essay," I think "something I or someone else had to write for school or another academic program, which is probably dry and boring and, if it's written by an adult, filled with large, professional-sounding terms that fly right over my head." (This is despite the fact that, for the past two years, I've had a chapter each year in Literature dedicated to essays and enjoyed it both years.) However, Diana Wynne Jones's style is anything but dry or boring, and certainly does not go right over my head. Reading these essays feels like listening to her talk to me in a friendly, conversational way, whether she's talking about writing or her life or "The Narrative Shape of the Lord of the Rings" (which sounds terribly imposing but is actually fascinating, if you like Tolkien). It's lovely.

Most of the essays in this book focus on Jones's thoughts on writing- both her own and writing in general. These I find fascinating; while some bits are similar to advice I've heard before, most is new and interesting and makes me say "Hmm, I never thought of that before." A few are specificially about other peoples's writing, notably that of Tolkien and Lewis (both of whom she studied under at Oxford). Of these, "The Narrative Shape of the Lord of the Rings" is the best- though I may be a bit biased because I don't agree with several of her opinions about and interpretations of Narnia. I rather wish I'd started this book a great deal sooner, so that I could've paused after reading "The Narrative Shape" and reread The Lord of the Rings, just so I could see again for myself the things she pointed out as interesting.

And, of course, many of the essays deal with her own life, especially her childhood- two specifically are about it, but it comes up in nearly every selection. These parts fascinate me as much as (or possibly more than) the rest, but also make me sad. Jones certainly did not have an easy life- which, I suppose, makes her all the more inspiring.

If you have never read anything by Diana Wynne Jones before, I probably wouldn't give this book to you as an introduction. It's a splendid book, and well-representative of her style, but I feel like you need at least a fair acquaintance with her fantasy books before you read this. (The Chronicles of Chrestomanci, Fire and Hemlock, and possibly Black Maria are the ones that seem to get referenced the most- which means I probably didn't get quite as much out of this book as I could've, since, of those three, I've only read The Chronicles of Chrestomanci. The other two are on my to-be-read list.) However, if you've read at least some of Diana Wynne Jones's books and loved them, then yes, yes, yes, read this book. You definitely won't regret it.

colinandersbrodd's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

A really good set of writings by Jones on her life and on writing. She repeats herself quite a bit across several essays and several years, but it is all quite well told and most of it really interesting (one can't help but be a bit awed by some of her experiences, including studying under C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien).

walte's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I have not read anything else by this author. The book was well-written and amusing in places. I enjoyed it.

toni_reads07's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

For any writer of the fantastic, any writer of work intended for young readers, this exquisite essay collection is your lighthouse.