Scan barcode
melanieboyer's review against another edition
4.0
Niccolo is no Lymond. I got bogged down in the middle. But the complexity is amazing and Dunnett is unmatched.
cosmogyral's review against another edition
3.5
I spent a lot of this book feeling like nothing was happening except making me distressed At the same time, a lot did happen that was interesting and fun! I look forward to seeing what happens to Nicholas next, and I hope my faves get more page time.
shiari's review against another edition
5.0
So much fun! Dunnett's characters, plots, and writing style are all richly complex and thoroughly enjoyable. I will have to read it again as I know I've missed things in this book, but I do not mind one bit.
sashas_books's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
emotional
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
5.0
I still don’t know where this series is going, and I am loving the journey.
Nicholas is coming into his own. There is a mission for him and the Charetty company (it’s mission of trade, naturally). He gets to assemble a team, and make people into a team. Thoughts on leadership and what people expect from their leader are woven into the book. It’s fascinating.
”For leadership was a dangerous drug. To watch other men’s errors was once an idle amusement; now it was an ache.”
Everything that makes Dunnett novels so special is here: the glories of her descriptive writing; historical details and settings that make you want to read up on so much (or to scour Wikipedia, at the very least); the adventures; the danger; the intrigues; the wonderful dialogues; the heartbreak… The villains are great – you love to hate them. Yet Dunnett writes such an unexpectedly poignant scene when one of them meets his end! Just like in the first book, the underlying intrigue is not revealed until the very end. At this point, I felt for Nicholas who wished to be free of both conscience and responsibility.
Games people play is another recurring theme in Dunnett’s books – games and their consequences. Yes, horrible things with overarching consequences may happen, even if you were ”only playing a game”. (Nicholas has now made toys for quite a few people, too. And none of them has had good things happen to them after that. What is this pattern about, I wonder?)
In this book, Nicholas shines a lot more than the supporting characters. I don’t mind this narrative choice, but I wanted to see more of everybody. Catherine de Charetty was an exception, she evolved in interesting ways. The company’s lawyer, Gregorio, had excellent POV chapters as well.
Oh, did I mention that Dunnett took me to Trebizond? To Trebizond! How cool is that? And I could see the city, the Citadel, the Emperor’s court, it was all right in front me. Thank you, book.
”The court spent much of the day making itself beautiful, in order to spend much of the rest of the day in a state of physical gratification.”
”Today, the sun was hazily warm, and the tulips lining the water channels seemed made of scarlet satin: the scent of narcissus and hyacinth was dizzying.”
The latter chapters were thrilling. I guessed some of the events at the very end, but not all, not all… One thing in particular left me reeling – not because I greatly cared for this character, but because of the consequences for all the others. I am guessing we’ll be seeing this play out in the next book!
I have written down too many wonderful quotes not to share at least some of them:
”He went to sea: the earth fell away and instead there was space, into which he sprang vividly whole.”
”Perfection would spoil you,” said John le Grant. ”The passengers knifing the crew, half the galley in holes, two priests and a whistle on board and the Turkish army ahead. It’s not a ship. It’s a nervous wreck, laddie.”
”You’re still planning. You’re up to something, aren’t you?”
”Yes, I am binding my bleeding arm,” said Nicholas.
”Do you not think me altruistic?”
”I didn’t think your highness knew the word,” Nicholas said.
”Nicholas formed the opinion that my lord Simon was untouched by time and probably by experience.”
”He wondered, drawing the new, shining blade, what other skills Simon would force him to master. Finding a method of resurrection, perhaps.”
Nicholas is coming into his own. There is a mission for him and the Charetty company (it’s mission of trade, naturally). He gets to assemble a team, and make people into a team. Thoughts on leadership and what people expect from their leader are woven into the book. It’s fascinating.
”For leadership was a dangerous drug. To watch other men’s errors was once an idle amusement; now it was an ache.”
Everything that makes Dunnett novels so special is here: the glories of her descriptive writing; historical details and settings that make you want to read up on so much (or to scour Wikipedia, at the very least); the adventures; the danger; the intrigues; the wonderful dialogues; the heartbreak… The villains are great – you love to hate them. Yet Dunnett writes such an unexpectedly poignant scene when one of them meets his end! Just like in the first book, the underlying intrigue is not revealed until the very end. At this point, I felt for Nicholas who wished to be free of both conscience and responsibility.
Games people play is another recurring theme in Dunnett’s books – games and their consequences. Yes, horrible things with overarching consequences may happen, even if you were ”only playing a game”. (Nicholas has now made toys for quite a few people, too. And none of them has had good things happen to them after that. What is this pattern about, I wonder?)
In this book, Nicholas shines a lot more than the supporting characters. I don’t mind this narrative choice, but I wanted to see more of everybody. Catherine de Charetty was an exception, she evolved in interesting ways. The company’s lawyer, Gregorio, had excellent POV chapters as well.
Oh, did I mention that Dunnett took me to Trebizond? To Trebizond! How cool is that? And I could see the city, the Citadel, the Emperor’s court, it was all right in front me. Thank you, book.
”The court spent much of the day making itself beautiful, in order to spend much of the rest of the day in a state of physical gratification.”
”Today, the sun was hazily warm, and the tulips lining the water channels seemed made of scarlet satin: the scent of narcissus and hyacinth was dizzying.”
The latter chapters were thrilling. I guessed some of the events at the very end, but not all, not all… One thing in particular left me reeling – not because I greatly cared for this character, but because of the consequences for all the others. I am guessing we’ll be seeing this play out in the next book!
I have written down too many wonderful quotes not to share at least some of them:
”He went to sea: the earth fell away and instead there was space, into which he sprang vividly whole.”
”Perfection would spoil you,” said John le Grant. ”The passengers knifing the crew, half the galley in holes, two priests and a whistle on board and the Turkish army ahead. It’s not a ship. It’s a nervous wreck, laddie.”
”You’re still planning. You’re up to something, aren’t you?”
”Yes, I am binding my bleeding arm,” said Nicholas.
”Do you not think me altruistic?”
”I didn’t think your highness knew the word,” Nicholas said.
”Nicholas formed the opinion that my lord Simon was untouched by time and probably by experience.”
”He wondered, drawing the new, shining blade, what other skills Simon would force him to master. Finding a method of resurrection, perhaps.”
hannahkk's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
seacrab1's review against another edition
4.0
First I must state how appreciative I am that there are threads and discussions out there by Dunnett fans discussing these wonderful yet maddening novels!
As is her style, she can say so little, so beautifully, and it hits me dead center, THEN turn around and be so vague that it leaves a giant gray blob in my brain. Ugh, I had forgotten about this dichotomy. But a little discussion surfing and some deep pondering of my own has diffused the gray blob some (it never goes away completely when reading her books).
I was a little thrown by the Venice scene with Simon, the daughters and Gregorio; I felt a little disappointed with the handling of such momentous news... too public, and slightly farcical, than it should have been. Still, I look forward to the next book, though I will read something lighter and fluffier before then!
As is her style, she can say so little, so beautifully, and it hits me dead center, THEN turn around and be so vague that it leaves a giant gray blob in my brain. Ugh, I had forgotten about this dichotomy. But a little discussion surfing and some deep pondering of my own has diffused the gray blob some (it never goes away completely when reading her books).
I was a little thrown by the Venice scene with Simon, the daughters and Gregorio; I felt a little disappointed with the handling of such momentous news... too public, and slightly farcical, than it should have been. Still, I look forward to the next book, though I will read something lighter and fluffier before then!
curtis49's review against another edition
4.0
One very special trait Dorothy Dunnett, the author, possesses in her writing is when she creates and develops a nefarious character, you the reader, will certainly loathe, detest, despise and wish any number of equally nefarious means to the character's demise. They appear and some receive their just deserves, others, I'm sure, are to remain in these tales of the [b:House of Niccolo Series|22231272|House of Niccolo Series (Niccolo Rising, The Spring of the Ram, Race of Scorpions, Scales of Gold, The Unicorn Hunt, To Lie with Lions, Caprice and Rondo, Gemini)|Dorothy Dunnett|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1400571529s/22231272.jpg|41572997] [bc:House of Niccolo Series|22231272|House of Niccolo Series (Niccolo Rising, The Spring of the Ram, Race of Scorpions, Scales of Gold, The Unicorn Hunt, To Lie with Lions, Caprice and Rondo, Gemini)|Dorothy Dunnett|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1400571529s/22231272.jpg|41572997].
As I have finished book two of the eight in this saga, I will refrain from any other reviews other than to let whoever is interested know that I'm moving on, or if something of note I think is worth penning, I will.
Onto book three, [b:Race of Scorpions|112083|Race of Scorpions (The House of Niccolo, #3)|Dorothy Dunnett|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1403190688s/112083.jpg|1694441][bc:Race of Scorpions|112083|Race of Scorpions (The House of Niccolo, #3)|Dorothy Dunnett|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1403190688s/112083.jpg|1694441].
Thank you once again, my Goodreads Italian friend, for recommending this compilation. :))
As I have finished book two of the eight in this saga, I will refrain from any other reviews other than to let whoever is interested know that I'm moving on, or if something of note I think is worth penning, I will.
Onto book three, [b:Race of Scorpions|112083|Race of Scorpions (The House of Niccolo, #3)|Dorothy Dunnett|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1403190688s/112083.jpg|1694441][bc:Race of Scorpions|112083|Race of Scorpions (The House of Niccolo, #3)|Dorothy Dunnett|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1403190688s/112083.jpg|1694441].
Thank you once again, my Goodreads Italian friend, for recommending this compilation. :))
rachellg's review against another edition
4.0
I don't know what to say! I still don't love Nicholas like I loved Francis Crawford; I have a much harder time getting a read on his character. Dunnett writes brilliant description, and some of the dialogue here is very funny. I googled something and spoiled myself twice for this book, which took a little of the fun out, which isn't the book's fault. Catherine drove me nuts in a very believable way. I still feel vaguely like the book is implying things I'm not quite picking up on (there is a mysterious and sexy woman who says heavily loaded and implicative things -- this is a trope Dunnett loves).
Clearly I enjoyed reading it, but I am at a loss to tell you why or why I didn't give it five stars without a few months of thinking about it, or spoiling everything.
Clearly I enjoyed reading it, but I am at a loss to tell you why or why I didn't give it five stars without a few months of thinking about it, or spoiling everything.
alisonabridged's review against another edition
adventurous
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0