Scan barcode
crafalsk264's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
informative
inspiring
reflective
slow-paced
3.5
I recently read a book (“The Diamond Eye”, Kate Quinn, March 2022) which is a fictional novel featuring Lyudmila Pavlichenko. I was fascinated by the premise of a female sniper in WWII so I went looking for this book which served as an inspiration for Quinn’s novel.
“A classic was once defined as a book you remember starting to read but you never stop reading or re-reading. This is such a book.” [Goodreads review, Willy Marz Thiessam, 01-25-2018]
In reviewing the reviews of this book, I was taken by this text from another reader’s review comments. It fits my personal definition of a “classic” better than any other definition. And this book is definitely a fit.
Lyudmila (“Mila”) was a University student working on her dissertation in History when Germany attacked Russia through Ukraine. She was the daughter of a communist party official and grew up as a pretty, privileged young woman. As part of her school sports activities, she got her first marksmanship training, winning all of the prizes and certificates available. So when she decided to enlist she was already a skilled shooter and with a couple of months’ training, she became a deadly sniper. Mila then describes her development as a sniper. During this time, she is wounded multiple times, completes 309 verified kills, receives the highest decorations for an infantry member, designed a program and then trained hundreds of snipers during the latter part of the War. In 1942-43, Mila made “good will” tours to a number of Allied countries including Britain, Canada and the U.S., usually in connection with some youth or young adult conference or sponspored event for international relations or working for peace. A major goal of these trips was to impress on the Allies that Russia was fighting the Nazis alone on the Eastern Front since mid-1941 and had lost men, resources and was the only thing keeping Hitler’s attention of away from full concentration on Central and Western Europe. On her trip to the US, she became friends with Eleanor Roosevelt who remained a pen pal years after she left the White. House. Due to Mila’s excellent language skills, she was also able to establish personal relations with others including Clementine Churchill who provided equipment to start a number of hospitals in Russia for casualties of war. After the War, Mila returned to her University education completing a degree in history from Kyiv University. But she was suffering greatly from her wounds and shell shock only living to 58.
An interesting historical side note is that Russia was the only Allied country in which women routinely served in the military forces including in combat positions. Women initially served in administrative or auxiliary positions. However, after Operation Barbarosa, Russia had such massive military losses that they had to rethink how to continue defending the country from the Nazis. From June, 1941 to the end of the War, more than 800,000 women served in the military (5% of all forces). Although many continued in support roles, there were great numbers in postings such as paramedics (40%), doctors (46%), surgeons (45%), medical assistants (57%) and nurses (100%). But there was a significant number of combat pilots, snipers, machine gunners, tank crew members and partisan resisters. After the War, most women left the military and attitudes and roles returned to more pre-War Norms. I found one estimate of the current Russian Armed Forces Ground Force is ~350,ooo and women make up about 10% or 35,000. Interesting……
killerwolf96's review against another edition
5.0
Major Lyudmila Pavlichenko was a Red Army sniper during World War II who attained 309 (!) kills in combat. This book details her transformation from a factory worker in Ukraine to one of the deadliest snipers in history.
It's a brilliant read, with chapters detailing her first 100 kills against the Romanians and then moving on to the German army. Her attention to detail with weapons is amazing - I often read memoirs where former soldiers just generally describe their guns as "tommy guns" or "machine guns" but Major Pavlichenko always details the full name of whichever weapon she is talking about, and also throws in some technical specs. The most interesting parts for me were the chapters in which she details a counter-sniping operation against a German sniper, and the chapters dealing with her speaking tour of the US and UK. It was interesting to note the attitudes of pre-war USA towards this woman, with reporters seeming to care more about the cut of her uniform and which colour of underwear she preferred rather than actually asking this soldier about life at war.
Definitely one of the best war memoirs I've read regarding the Eastern Front of WWII, and well worth a read to anyone interested in snipers or World War II in general.
It's a brilliant read, with chapters detailing her first 100 kills against the Romanians and then moving on to the German army. Her attention to detail with weapons is amazing - I often read memoirs where former soldiers just generally describe their guns as "tommy guns" or "machine guns" but Major Pavlichenko always details the full name of whichever weapon she is talking about, and also throws in some technical specs. The most interesting parts for me were the chapters in which she details a counter-sniping operation against a German sniper, and the chapters dealing with her speaking tour of the US and UK. It was interesting to note the attitudes of pre-war USA towards this woman, with reporters seeming to care more about the cut of her uniform and which colour of underwear she preferred rather than actually asking this soldier about life at war.
Definitely one of the best war memoirs I've read regarding the Eastern Front of WWII, and well worth a read to anyone interested in snipers or World War II in general.
jellifysh's review against another edition
4.0
It only took me six and a half months to finish Lady Death, but I did it!
Rtc
Rtc
dkevanstoronto's review against another edition
5.0
A classic was once defined as a book you remember starting to read but you never stop reading and re-reading. This is such a book.
The book is the autobiography of the Russian sniper Ludmilla Pavlichenko. Pavlichenko was exceptional in many regards, not least for her ability to kill hundreds of Fascists during the Second World War. Her skill in marksmanship was a natural in born ability, but her military training and understanding given to her in her youth by her father created a very acute observer of the start of Fascist Germany's invasion of the Soviet Union. The level of detail is only matched by Pvlichenko's ability to write with precision and clarity. On this level the book opens to the reader the sense of being caught up and thrown into the cataclysm which occurred. The gradual sense of the immensity of what occurred and the level of sacrifice the situation demanded is given with a compassionate regard and at the same time professional military detail. There is no other book I can think of that is remarkable in this sense to this degree.
Then there is her ability to speak English which gave her the chance to become deep friends with Eleanor Roosevelt when on a tour of the USA to promote a second front in the war. This odd friendship forms most of the second half of the book. From the depths of war torn hell to sitting half naked on a bed sewing alterations on pajamas with Eleanor Roosevelt you probably will not find a more bizarre combination in a biography.
Quite apart form all that it is very well written. I would have to say this is one of the top five books I've read in my fifty years of life. This book is a masterpiece of literature. To such a life the literary quality should be exceptional and it is. This is a book you want to read over and over.
The book is the autobiography of the Russian sniper Ludmilla Pavlichenko. Pavlichenko was exceptional in many regards, not least for her ability to kill hundreds of Fascists during the Second World War. Her skill in marksmanship was a natural in born ability, but her military training and understanding given to her in her youth by her father created a very acute observer of the start of Fascist Germany's invasion of the Soviet Union. The level of detail is only matched by Pvlichenko's ability to write with precision and clarity. On this level the book opens to the reader the sense of being caught up and thrown into the cataclysm which occurred. The gradual sense of the immensity of what occurred and the level of sacrifice the situation demanded is given with a compassionate regard and at the same time professional military detail. There is no other book I can think of that is remarkable in this sense to this degree.
Then there is her ability to speak English which gave her the chance to become deep friends with Eleanor Roosevelt when on a tour of the USA to promote a second front in the war. This odd friendship forms most of the second half of the book. From the depths of war torn hell to sitting half naked on a bed sewing alterations on pajamas with Eleanor Roosevelt you probably will not find a more bizarre combination in a biography.
Quite apart form all that it is very well written. I would have to say this is one of the top five books I've read in my fifty years of life. This book is a masterpiece of literature. To such a life the literary quality should be exceptional and it is. This is a book you want to read over and over.
lisa_h71's review against another edition
3.0
3 1/2 stars. Interesting read. Lyudmila was a remarkable young woman. I especially enjoyed her details regarding her world tour and friendship with Eleanor Roosevelt.
empressofeverything's review against another edition
2.0
A very...no nonsense book, tbh. I didn’t love it but it was interesting to read.
bodhishevikbolsattva's review against another edition
4.0
And that is another book for the month of January.
Lyudmila covers a lot of ground in these memoirs. Her apparent destiny to be a sharpshooter and innocence before the beginning of WW2. The destitute conditions of the Red army and her fallen comrades. The depravity of the Nazis on everyday people. Thrilling sniper duels and trophies. Brushes with death and almost mystical survival. The devotion of citizens, sacrificing what little they had to better care for the soldiers. Falling in love and having to see her lover pass on the battlefield. Her travels to other countries and meeting figures like CHARLIE CHAPLIN, Eleanore Roosevelt and Winston Churchill, and also her disappointments. A fatherly reconciliation with Joseph Stalin.
It all brings a welcome new perspective to the saturated arena of WW2 lit, and shouldn't be overlooked.
Lyudmila covers a lot of ground in these memoirs. Her apparent destiny to be a sharpshooter and innocence before the beginning of WW2. The destitute conditions of the Red army and her fallen comrades. The depravity of the Nazis on everyday people. Thrilling sniper duels and trophies. Brushes with death and almost mystical survival. The devotion of citizens, sacrificing what little they had to better care for the soldiers. Falling in love and having to see her lover pass on the battlefield. Her travels to other countries and meeting figures like CHARLIE CHAPLIN, Eleanore Roosevelt and Winston Churchill, and also her disappointments. A fatherly reconciliation with Joseph Stalin.
It all brings a welcome new perspective to the saturated arena of WW2 lit, and shouldn't be overlooked.