Scan barcode
Reviews
The Bardic Book of Becoming: An Introduction to Modern Druidry by Ivan McBeth, Fearn Lickfield
bamboobones_rory's review
1.0
This was very difficult for me to get through- a friend who is studying to be a druid rec'ed it to me. It was hard to get through because I am familiar with Irish mythology and folk religion, and have spent time digging into mythology and the early celtic church. While this has an anglo-saxon focus and was focused on recreated traditions, it was so rife with historically inaccuracy it was so hard for me to read. I appreciate that people of European descent should engage with their past, traditions, and connection to the Earth, without appropriating closed cultures. I can get behind all humans seeking to connect with the Earth that we cannot disentangle ourselves from, and looking to our family histories. But I wish this book was more open and clear that they are created a modern practice- while helpful to some people in connecting with the land and their inner work- and that it is not based in history, but inspired by. It is also frustrating to me that the English men who founded "modern druidry" are the same who looked down upon the Irish language (and Gaelic and Welsh)- and did not seek to look those existing and living folk traditions due to ethnic prejudice.
laurareads87's review against another edition
informative
slow-paced
I'm going to refrain from giving this a star rating. I read this book as part of the curriculum for the AODA, and it's interesting as a part of the Druidry revival's history. Nichols founded OBOD, a significant contemporary order, and he has lots of interesting things to say about various Druid leaders that came before him; as a text that is part of Druidry's history it's an interesting read but it is not a good source about history. There are definite issues with accuracy, and lots of totally unfounded speculation; while some footnotes are present, many ideas are simply stated with no references. I think the contemporary audience who will be interested in this book is very, very limited.
Minor: Sexism
hissingpotatoes's review
4.0
An excellent introduction to Druidry that does a great job of balancing theory with practicality and making it clear how each feed into and build off of the other. The book includes meditations, rituals, and activities you can start implementing at home right away (in fact, I already have).
I have questions about some aspects of Druidry presented that either didn't make sense or seemed contradictory, but I'm not sure if that's from McBeth's writing or larger Druidic teachings themselves. Also sometimes the book had overly self-helpy marketing wording ("do this stuff to become your most amazing self!"). To be fair the book includes actual, implementable methods to get there, but the style can be off-putting.
The foreword and introduction were both written by people who knew McBeth and are therefore among the most touching, contextualized forewords/introductions I've read. McBeth peppered his own experiences throughout the book to illustrate his points at exactly the right times.
I have questions about some aspects of Druidry presented that either didn't make sense or seemed contradictory, but I'm not sure if that's from McBeth's writing or larger Druidic teachings themselves. Also sometimes the book had overly self-helpy marketing wording ("do this stuff to become your most amazing self!"). To be fair the book includes actual, implementable methods to get there, but the style can be off-putting.
The foreword and introduction were both written by people who knew McBeth and are therefore among the most touching, contextualized forewords/introductions I've read. McBeth peppered his own experiences throughout the book to illustrate his points at exactly the right times.
annarella's review
5.0
A very interesting book, full of facts and recommended to whoever is interested in understanding what druidry is.
Many thanks to Welser Books and Edelweiss for this ARC
Many thanks to Welser Books and Edelweiss for this ARC
annarella's review against another edition
5.0
A very interesting book, full of facts and recommended to whoever is interested in understanding what druidry is.
Many thanks to Welser Books and Edelweiss for this ARC
Many thanks to Welser Books and Edelweiss for this ARC