Scan barcode
Reviews
PLUTO: Naoki Urasawa x Osamu Tezuka, Volume 008 by Osamu Tezuka, Naoki Urasawa, Takashi Nagasaki
renfieldscat's review against another edition
5.0
The ending of one of the greatest manga series ever written. I don’t think it pulls off the final trick at the end, but it hardly matters whenever everything was so expertly paced and plotted.
brokensandals's review against another edition
3.0
The reviews led me to expect a lot from this series. I may be missing some relevant cultural background (such as prior knowledge of Astro Boy) needed to appreciate it - it was enjoyable, but nonsensical elements in the plot and setting detracted.
scottmedlock's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
5.0
omredondo's review against another edition
4.5
Tomo final de Pluto. La trama me ha gustado, pero he bajado la nota a 4.5 porque apenas hay personajes femeninos relevantes
marikaisabelle's review against another edition
4.0
J'ai vraiment, vraiment adoré cette série, qui m'aura arraché quelques larmes plus d'une fois. Une très belle découverte totalement par hasard que je suis très heureuse d'avoir faite.
thisotherbookaccount's review against another edition
2.0
Follow me on Instagram: www.instagram.com/thisotherbookaccount
[I’ve decided to post the reviews of the final three books at the same time]
Here we are at the end of Urasawa’s beloved manga series, and I am sorry to say that, overall, it’s a major disappointment. Instead of going out on a high, the conclusion of this ‘acclaimed’ series is more akin to a hot, wet fart in an enclosed bathroom. It smells and, worse, it LINGERS.
Every issue that I had with the series is compounded here. Urasawa is to plot threads the way a three-year-old is to shoelaces. Instead of a logical, satisfying ending, plots are left dangling or ignored altogether. Even the ones he bothers with end up in dead knots. There’s literally a scene about 20 pages from the end where a group of characters ask each other, “What is Bora? What is Pluto? Who is Abdullah? WHAT IS HAPPENING?”
The fuck I know, dear manga characters. We are just as confused. It is as if Urasawa himself didn’t know what the hell he was writing. It’s like reaching the final act in the Harry Potter series, and our main characters asking, “Wait, which one of you is He Who Shall Not Be Named again?” It’s that bad.
Urasawa then adds an end-of-the-world plot presumably written by the same three-year-old who had trouble with his laces. As if an evil-hate-filled robot wasn’t enough, there’s somehow an ancient volcano about to explode because reasons.
Overall, the manga series is a beautiful, hot mess. The art is consistently great throughout, but the story and characters just do not hold up. It disguises its simplicity with fake intellectualism, and the action is nothing more exciting than seeing a child bang plastic action figures together on the bedroom floor.
Don’t believe what manga fans tell you about this series. Skip it.
[I’ve decided to post the reviews of the final three books at the same time]
Here we are at the end of Urasawa’s beloved manga series, and I am sorry to say that, overall, it’s a major disappointment. Instead of going out on a high, the conclusion of this ‘acclaimed’ series is more akin to a hot, wet fart in an enclosed bathroom. It smells and, worse, it LINGERS.
Every issue that I had with the series is compounded here. Urasawa is to plot threads the way a three-year-old is to shoelaces. Instead of a logical, satisfying ending, plots are left dangling or ignored altogether. Even the ones he bothers with end up in dead knots. There’s literally a scene about 20 pages from the end where a group of characters ask each other, “What is Bora? What is Pluto? Who is Abdullah? WHAT IS HAPPENING?”
The fuck I know, dear manga characters. We are just as confused. It is as if Urasawa himself didn’t know what the hell he was writing. It’s like reaching the final act in the Harry Potter series, and our main characters asking, “Wait, which one of you is He Who Shall Not Be Named again?” It’s that bad.
Urasawa then adds an end-of-the-world plot presumably written by the same three-year-old who had trouble with his laces. As if an evil-hate-filled robot wasn’t enough, there’s somehow an ancient volcano about to explode because reasons.
Overall, the manga series is a beautiful, hot mess. The art is consistently great throughout, but the story and characters just do not hold up. It disguises its simplicity with fake intellectualism, and the action is nothing more exciting than seeing a child bang plastic action figures together on the bedroom floor.
Don’t believe what manga fans tell you about this series. Skip it.
piedrapapeld20's review against another edition
5.0
Sirva esto como reseña de toda la saga. Urasawa me ha vuelto a dejar enganchado, como lo hizo con 20th Century Boys, y lo ha hecho con un drama que habla de una posguerra y de como las heridas nunca quedan cerradas, la venganza sigue adelante y los sentimientos extremos son los que nos marcan.
Imprescindible.
Imprescindible.
kouson77's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5