Scan barcode
verkisto's review against another edition
3.0
So, here's an oddity for you: A Tim Powers novel that takes place in the future. I'm so accustomed to Powers using real history to tell a spooky fantasy tale that I was taken by surprise by this book. I mean, I wasn't worried -- Tim Powers is an excellent author to lead you by the hand through his unique imagination -- but my expectations were different.
The story here is set in Los Angeles a few hundred years after a nuclear war, where a religion has formed around a mysterious character named Jaybush. The main character, Rivas, is an ex-member of the cult, which puts him in a good position to rescue people from it, and he spent time working as a redeemer, who would go in and retrieve people from the Jaybush cult for the right price. Now, he's a gunner who performs music at bars, but when someone comes in and requests his services as a redeemer to rescue his ex-girlfriend, he finds it hard to say no.
Powers uses modern technology in a wasted future to great success. You can see on the cover of the book that one of the characters drives a car led by horses, and at one point in the story, he notes that people still let their vehicles stand, boarded and ready, for a minute or two on cold mornings before flicking the horses' reins to get going. "Toothtalkers" also appear in the novel, as metal-toothed prophets who receive messages from the spirits in their teeth. Our main character, however, tells us that it's been at least ten years since he heard a convincing toothtalker, and even then only on the tops of mountains. He also notes that the amount of metal on modern toothtalkers' teeth is only for show, as the real toothtalkers he remembers only had trace amounts of metal in their teeth. It's a neat riff on what Arthur C. Clarke said: "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." These kinds of co-opted technologies set a tone for the novel, where you expect the supernatural elements to somehow tie in to older technologies. As the story progresses, though, it's harder to make that connection, as the pseudo-religious aspects of it defy explanation.
Powers' usual straightforward style and characterization is present here, and will be familiar to those who enjoy his books. The plot, though, is a bit substandard. It doesn't feel as tight as his other books I've read, and it seems that Powers relies too much on coincidence to keep the story moving forward. When Rivas finds himself stranded in a big city, he remembers someone he once knew there, and is able to get help from her. She's not mentioned previously in the story, and once she provides assistance, she disappears from the story. This kind of thing happens more than once as the plot gets further and further along, and it didn't sit well with me.
The book is a little disappointing, partly because the conclusion seemed a little too ridiculous, and partly because Powers has written some damn fine novels. When Powers releases a mediocre book like this one (especially after the brilliant The Anubis Gates), it becomes one of those "This would have been a great first novel for someone else, but isn't up to the standard Powers has set with his other books" book. On the other hand, I found myself better able to follow what was going on here, which is more than I can say for his well-received The Stress of Her Regard. I can see people wanting to read it, because it's Tim Powers, but I'd save it for last; it's simply not among his best efforts.
The story here is set in Los Angeles a few hundred years after a nuclear war, where a religion has formed around a mysterious character named Jaybush. The main character, Rivas, is an ex-member of the cult, which puts him in a good position to rescue people from it, and he spent time working as a redeemer, who would go in and retrieve people from the Jaybush cult for the right price. Now, he's a gunner who performs music at bars, but when someone comes in and requests his services as a redeemer to rescue his ex-girlfriend, he finds it hard to say no.
Powers uses modern technology in a wasted future to great success. You can see on the cover of the book that one of the characters drives a car led by horses, and at one point in the story, he notes that people still let their vehicles stand, boarded and ready, for a minute or two on cold mornings before flicking the horses' reins to get going. "Toothtalkers" also appear in the novel, as metal-toothed prophets who receive messages from the spirits in their teeth. Our main character, however, tells us that it's been at least ten years since he heard a convincing toothtalker, and even then only on the tops of mountains. He also notes that the amount of metal on modern toothtalkers' teeth is only for show, as the real toothtalkers he remembers only had trace amounts of metal in their teeth. It's a neat riff on what Arthur C. Clarke said: "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." These kinds of co-opted technologies set a tone for the novel, where you expect the supernatural elements to somehow tie in to older technologies. As the story progresses, though, it's harder to make that connection, as the pseudo-religious aspects of it defy explanation.
Powers' usual straightforward style and characterization is present here, and will be familiar to those who enjoy his books. The plot, though, is a bit substandard. It doesn't feel as tight as his other books I've read, and it seems that Powers relies too much on coincidence to keep the story moving forward. When Rivas finds himself stranded in a big city, he remembers someone he once knew there, and is able to get help from her. She's not mentioned previously in the story, and once she provides assistance, she disappears from the story. This kind of thing happens more than once as the plot gets further and further along, and it didn't sit well with me.
The book is a little disappointing, partly because the conclusion seemed a little too ridiculous, and partly because Powers has written some damn fine novels. When Powers releases a mediocre book like this one (especially after the brilliant The Anubis Gates), it becomes one of those "This would have been a great first novel for someone else, but isn't up to the standard Powers has set with his other books" book. On the other hand, I found myself better able to follow what was going on here, which is more than I can say for his well-received The Stress of Her Regard. I can see people wanting to read it, because it's Tim Powers, but I'd save it for last; it's simply not among his best efforts.
nwhyte's review against another edition
One of Powers' most sustainedly bizarre novels; tremendously engaging.
tarabyt3's review against another edition
3.0
Tim Powers has a rather raw way of writing that is both intriguing and alienating at once for me. The book has aged well enough, but I found a lot of the plot devices to be a bit too convenient. So while it was an interesting read, it was mostly just a fun one for me.
abookishtype's review against another edition
4.0
I’ve been a fan of Tim Powers for years, ever since I read Last Call and Declare. There’s no one else quite like him in fiction. His books are strange and original and fantastical. Reading them is an immersive experience where you have to learn what’s going on with a minimum of expository text; you learn everything from context. Dinner at Deviant’s Palace is not a new book. It was originally published back in the 1980s. But because it was set in a future, post-apocalyptic version of Los Angeles, it doesn’t feel dated at all. Even early in his career, Powers’ style is still well developed and masterly...
Read the rest of my review at A Bookish Type. I received a free copy of this book from NetGalley at review consideration.
Read the rest of my review at A Bookish Type. I received a free copy of this book from NetGalley at review consideration.
una_10bananas's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
riduidel's review against another edition
1.0
[b:Le palais du déviant|209700|Dinner at Deviant's Palace|Tim Powers|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1212509773s/209700.jpg|937394] est un roman de [a:Tim Powers|947|William Shakespeare|http://photo.goodreads.com/authors/1179017891p2/947.jpg] dans lequel on suit les aventures d’un ancien héros (oui, enfin bon, son boulot n’importait guère, mais il sauvait des jeunes en détresse et, globalement, était apprécié) qui repart pour le souvenir d’un ancien amour.
Pour être clair, c’est sans doute le plus faible des romans de Powers que j’ai lu. Dans ce roman, on retrouve en partie le mélange qui a fait le succès des [b:voies d’Anubis|142296|The Anubis Gates|Tim Powers|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1172136827s/142296.jpg|2193115], mais sans beaucoup d’inspiration. En effet, le héros vogue de mésaventure en mésaventure, aussi variées les unes que les autres, mais sans réelle unité.
De plus, le décor post-apocalyptique est pour le moins décevant. Hors un résidu de Los Angeles, il n’y a qu’une morne plaine, évidement radioactive, à se mettre sous la main. Et tout ça pour quoi ? Pour aller sortir une donzelle d’une secte (au début) avant de se rendre compte que ce morceau de terre n’est finallement qu’un rêve incarné, bien malgré le rêveur. Bref, j’ai été bien déçu, et je ne recommande pas cette lecture.
Pour être clair, c’est sans doute le plus faible des romans de Powers que j’ai lu. Dans ce roman, on retrouve en partie le mélange qui a fait le succès des [b:voies d’Anubis|142296|The Anubis Gates|Tim Powers|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1172136827s/142296.jpg|2193115], mais sans beaucoup d’inspiration. En effet, le héros vogue de mésaventure en mésaventure, aussi variées les unes que les autres, mais sans réelle unité.
De plus, le décor post-apocalyptique est pour le moins décevant. Hors un résidu de Los Angeles, il n’y a qu’une morne plaine, évidement radioactive, à se mettre sous la main. Et tout ça pour quoi ? Pour aller sortir une donzelle d’une secte (au début) avant de se rendre compte que ce morceau de terre n’est finallement qu’un rêve incarné, bien malgré le rêveur. Bref, j’ai été bien déçu, et je ne recommande pas cette lecture.
honniker's review against another edition
2.0
This is one of those cases where I thought I was really going to enjoy this book based on the description. Post apocalyptic and a cult? awesome! I finished the book, but had a hard time getting into it. I didn't really enjoy it. It's not that it's a badly written book, or that their are errors and things, it just turned out that I wasn't a huge fan of this book. You might like it, but it just wasn't my cup of tea.
joannawnyc's review against another edition
3.0
Shows that Powers had his style down pat quite early on, though it didn't really flesh out till later. Quite enjoyable! Really more of a 3.5, but I rounded up out of sentiment.