I’m not quite sure how I feel about this one.
The first chapter was triggering and quite painful, but I wanted to pursue due to good reviews.
I loved reading about Tess and Arcady’s life, but I had so much anger towards Adam. I couldn’t connect with him at all.
Interesting read, but wouldn’t recommend if others are triggered by abuse.

I owned this for ages before I actually read it, because I was wondering if I really wanted to read another holocaust novel. Well, this book has a lot else to offer the genre. It is a dual timeline book, with unlikable but compelling characters, an unpredictable plot and a a fresh feel. Liam Pieper's skills as a writer allow the reader to take this journey with him, one that, in the hands of a less capable author, might be a little outlandish. I'm glad I finally took this off the bottom of my TBR pile.

Good god. I've finally finished this bloody book. I must say I'm not really a fan. I didn't connect with the characters, I particularly hated Adam right from the beginning. There was a surprise at the end which I didn't see coming, but overall I forced myself to finish this book.

4.5 stars! I enjoyed this book immensely! I love a good unlikeable character, and Adam is exactly that! I liked the parallel storylines of Adam in contemporary Melbourne contrasted with Arkady in Auschwitz, as well as the contrasts between how their characters were portrayed- Arkady as gentle and kind, and his grandson Adam as a self-centred businessman. A theme of survival ran through the novel, in an obvious way regarding Arkady's imprisonment during the holocaust, and also in the sense that Adam is struggling to survive the consequences of his own horrendous behaviour and decisions. And then right when you think it couldn't get any worse, THAT REVELATION. THAT TWIST. WHAT A TWIST! Overall, one of the most well-written books I've read in a while, I couldn't put it down!

There was a great twist, and it was interesting enough that I finished it in one evening. But reading it was a continual exercise in suspending my dislike for the three main characters, whom I found unrelatable and almost unbelievable. Adam’s incompetence is belied by the success of his business, Tess’s naïveté is infuriating given her set-up as a smart, independent woman, and Arkady’s benign, comforting nature is almost incredible once you reach the end of the book (such a waste of an opportunity to foreshadow). I dislike most fiction about the Holocaust, as I find the cruelty and suffering is often exploited as an abhorrent plot point, and I felt similarly about the historical sections here. The sentence where Arkady compares hospital food to Auschwitz food was terrible. Some plot points weren’t well developed, like the blackmailer who was inexplicably satisfied, and John somehow knowing about Arkady’s true past. So while it was a compelling read, I’m dissatisfied because it could have been a lot better.

The Toymaker has been sitting on my TBR shelf for months (yes, I need a shelf now and I'm a little ashamed). Finally I had the inspiration to pick it up and discovered that it was nothing like I had imagined. Generally historical fiction or books that deal with WWII tell these absolutely harrowing tales, yes, but filled with a little hope in the form of a brave protagonist. Someone that see the evil and works to stem it, either overtly or in secret. Often these characters become dear to you. This is not one of those books. This book will not give you all the feels. In fact, I most likely will not read this book again. In saying all that this book is masterfully crafted and will leave you with a profound feeling upon finishing the pages. The story starts with Adam, the owner of a large toy company built from the ground up by his grandfather, Arkady, who escaped the horrors of Auschwitz to immigrate to Australia. The story is told form the perspective of Adam, Arkady and Adam's wife Tess, who develops a special bond with Arkady.


The more I think about this book the more I am in awe of Pieper's talent for crafting a novel. This book just cracks over 250 pages and for an author to create such a strong piece of work in such a short amount of time is impressive. I started this book late at night, just to read a few pages before turning in. Next minute (or hour, really) I found myself 150 pages deep and still not wanting to go to sleep. I even woke up early the next morning (on a Sunday, no less) just to finish the story. Another aspect I respect is how attached I became to the book despite having no real love for any of the characters, in fact some were downright reprehensible. So much of my attachment to other novels comes from the characters and to build such a strong novel without that fall back is masterful.



I read more than a few negative reviews about this book that mentioned not making it past he first chapter of the book, finding Adam and awful character that they refused to read about. I feel this initial reaction leads you to missing out on a unique experience. Books aren't always designed to make you feel comfortable. Characters and themes can be unpleasant to read about but sometimes there is so much to be gained from challenging yourself. This is one of those times. While reading this novel was an important literary experience where you learn all about just what humans will do to survive I am sure it is not an experience I will repeat. After the well-executed plot twists and turns are revealed to you and you have absorbed the lessons on offer I don't feel there is much more than can be gain from further reads. My impressions from this book will linger on without that. In fact my copy of this book already has a books on the rails sticker on it and ready to go, to impact this masterful novel on an unsuspecting commuter.



I would highly recommend this book to anyone, just be prepared to be a little uncomfortable with aspects of the plot at times. This book is definitely worth the challenge though. The lengths that humans will go to in order to preserve their owns lives are incredible. There is so much to be learned about human nature and not all of it is pretty but I'm sure we are all aware of that. Pieper has an incredible gift in the way he constructs and writes a novel and not many writers could pull off such a story. I give The Toymaker four toy dolls that Arkady built this story upon.

Clever little engaging read portraying nasty bits of human nature packaged in a few different ways. I'm ready for some light comic stuff now please Mr Pieper.

A fascinating story, well told.