Scan barcode
marieburton2004's review against another edition
4.0
http://www.burtonbookreview.com/2014/03/tide-and-tempest-by-elizabeth-ludwig.html
Having loved Ludwig's last two novels in this series, I knew I would love this one! The only thing disappointing was the NetGalley version was missing the letter f's in words such as 'stiffened' and 'difficult' and many others throughout, and still I managed to really enjoy the book. That is testament to a good story, people! I loved the setting where once again we are transported back in time to the old time New York where it seems Irishman are a dime a dozen. They are a mixture of good and evil, and you never knew who to trust when it comes to the Fenians.
Our heroine Tillie was a member of the boardinghouse in the last book when we met her as a grieving waif-like of a girl and Captain Morgan feels responsible for her loved one's death aboard his ship. He begins to realize that there are many mysteries that begin to twist around him that all lead back to that first death on his ship. Tillie is a target, and Morgan and his brother are determined to protect Tillie as she has no one else in New York to do so.
Though the previous characters are supporting of the big picture and we are focused on another set of new characters with this intriguing Irish in America tale there is a lot of a political slant with many different names to sort through. If you haven't read the first two in the series then this book may be a bit confusing to understand when it comes to the Fenians and their movement. If you have kept up with the series, this next installment won't disappoint as the writing style is fluid and fast paced. Though I would have liked a bit more details of the previous characters (Ana and Cara are simply mentioned), the story holds its own and makes reading it worthwhile. The faith theme is tiny and barely noticeable as it focuses on Morgan's sacrifice, and while there is a lot of love for our main characters I would have enjoyed a bit more on brother Cass and have to wonder if there is another book coming in the series. It seems that since the big picture of the Celt is finally cleared up this may be the last one but we can always hope!
Having loved Ludwig's last two novels in this series, I knew I would love this one! The only thing disappointing was the NetGalley version was missing the letter f's in words such as 'stiffened' and 'difficult' and many others throughout, and still I managed to really enjoy the book. That is testament to a good story, people! I loved the setting where once again we are transported back in time to the old time New York where it seems Irishman are a dime a dozen. They are a mixture of good and evil, and you never knew who to trust when it comes to the Fenians.
Our heroine Tillie was a member of the boardinghouse in the last book when we met her as a grieving waif-like of a girl and Captain Morgan feels responsible for her loved one's death aboard his ship. He begins to realize that there are many mysteries that begin to twist around him that all lead back to that first death on his ship. Tillie is a target, and Morgan and his brother are determined to protect Tillie as she has no one else in New York to do so.
Though the previous characters are supporting of the big picture and we are focused on another set of new characters with this intriguing Irish in America tale there is a lot of a political slant with many different names to sort through. If you haven't read the first two in the series then this book may be a bit confusing to understand when it comes to the Fenians and their movement. If you have kept up with the series, this next installment won't disappoint as the writing style is fluid and fast paced. Though I would have liked a bit more details of the previous characters (Ana and Cara are simply mentioned), the story holds its own and makes reading it worthwhile. The faith theme is tiny and barely noticeable as it focuses on Morgan's sacrifice, and while there is a lot of love for our main characters I would have enjoyed a bit more on brother Cass and have to wonder if there is another book coming in the series. It seems that since the big picture of the Celt is finally cleared up this may be the last one but we can always hope!
tiger_of_mu's review against another edition
5.0
I have absolutely loved reading this book! The characters are fantastic, and there is a great ebb and flow of intrigue and mystery.
sarah_reading_party's review against another edition
3.0
This novel, like the other two in the series [No Safe Harbor and Safe Road Home], is rich in historical detail. It’s obvious the author has spent a lot of time researching the history of revolution and freedom in Ireland. The group that’s heavily discussed in this series is the Fenians, and it was very interesting to learn about their work during this time.
I really enjoyed how detailed the author was in regard to Irish customs, language, and names. However, there was SO many new names/cultural items/groups in this book and the series that I got a bit confused. The story was just so broad and there were so many characters that I really had to pay attention to keep up with the action.
The suspense, not the romance element, was my favorite part of the book. It was so intriguing! I couldn’t wait to learn more about Tillie’s story–her past and her future.
Captain Morgan and his brother, Cass, play a huge role in this book. It was fun reading their interactions and their dual feelings towards Tillie. :)
Overall, this is just the kind of book I love. History, romance, suspense… and well researched and written to boot! Though it’s the conclusion to a great series, it definitely works as a stand alone novel. You’ll love it!
Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this book from Bethany House Publishers. However, I was not required to write a positive review. The thoughts expressed above are entirely my own. Thanks to Bethany House for the chance to read this great book!
bekaaaah's review against another edition
3.0
Tillie McGrath left Ireland with her fiancé hoping for a better life. When her fiancé dies on their way to America, she’s left with a broken heart and torn dreams. Captain Keondric Morgan has never forgotten Tillie since her stay on his ship. When he discovers that Tillie’s fiancé was actually murdered, not just sick, he seeks out Tillie to make sure she’s okay and begin investigations on the murder. What they discover puts them all in grave danger as they uncover a plot that is way beyond their imaginings.
Tide and Tempest was mysterious, cute, and suspenseful! All of the characters were lovable and endearing, especially Morgan’s brother Cass. Tillie annoyed me at times, but by the end I liked her. The plot was very interesting; it kept me guessing at what was going to happen. The dialogue and scene was authentic, I felt as if I had been brought back in time! My favorite part of the story was when Tillie finally realized that she had to forgive herself to move on. It made me realize that most of the time we are what’s holding us back.
Overall I liked Tide and Tempest for being an entertaining, sweet, and suspenseful historical read! I love it when books teach you little lessons and this one had a few gems. I would recommend it to all historical fiction lovers. I am looking forward to reading more of the Edge of Freedom books!
**I received this book for free from Bethany House Publishing in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts are completely my own.
Tide and Tempest was mysterious, cute, and suspenseful! All of the characters were lovable and endearing, especially Morgan’s brother Cass. Tillie annoyed me at times, but by the end I liked her. The plot was very interesting; it kept me guessing at what was going to happen. The dialogue and scene was authentic, I felt as if I had been brought back in time! My favorite part of the story was when Tillie finally realized that she had to forgive herself to move on. It made me realize that most of the time we are what’s holding us back.
Overall I liked Tide and Tempest for being an entertaining, sweet, and suspenseful historical read! I love it when books teach you little lessons and this one had a few gems. I would recommend it to all historical fiction lovers. I am looking forward to reading more of the Edge of Freedom books!
**I received this book for free from Bethany House Publishing in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts are completely my own.
sarahs_readingparty's review against another edition
3.0
This novel, like the other two in the series [No Safe Harbor and Safe Road Home], is rich in historical detail. It’s obvious the author has spent a lot of time researching the history of revolution and freedom in Ireland. The group that’s heavily discussed in this series is the Fenians, and it was very interesting to learn about their work during this time.
I really enjoyed how detailed the author was in regard to Irish customs, language, and names. However, there was SO many new names/cultural items/groups in this book and the series that I got a bit confused. The story was just so broad and there were so many characters that I really had to pay attention to keep up with the action.
The suspense, not the romance element, was my favorite part of the book. It was so intriguing! I couldn’t wait to learn more about Tillie’s story–her past and her future.
Captain Morgan and his brother, Cass, play a huge role in this book. It was fun reading their interactions and their dual feelings towards Tillie. :)
Overall, this is just the kind of book I love. History, romance, suspense… and well researched and written to boot! Though it’s the conclusion to a great series, it definitely works as a stand alone novel. You’ll love it!
Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this book from Bethany House Publishers. However, I was not required to write a positive review. The thoughts expressed above are entirely my own. Thanks to Bethany House for the chance to read this great book!
booksoneveryshelf's review against another edition
4.0
Excellent end to the series - 4 ½ stars
Tide and Tempest is the final book in Elizabeth Ludwig’s Edge of Freedom series and I’m sorry to see it end! I loved Roarke, Cara, Eoghan, Ana, Tillie, and now Keondric! I became so attached to them! They were like great friends! But, the wonderful thing about books is that I can go back and “visit” them again.
I had loved Tillie’s character since the beginning and couldn’t wait to see where Elizabeth would take her story. I’m very happy to say that it was even better than I had imagined. The new members of the cast were interesting and everyone was well rounded. I hope Cass one day receives his own story! I loved him! (sorry if that is a spoiler)
Keondric may have been my favorite hero, I’m not sure. Though I did love Roarke and Eoghan, too. He was the prefect match for Tillie and brought out the best in her, which was fun to see, since she was rather quiet in the other books.
This is a book about forgiveness and surrendering our plans to God. Tillie had spent the last 10 months of her life feeling guilty and believing God would punish her for her past, or that she must pay penance for her sins. She had to learn that when God forgives, it is gone. He washes the sin away, never to be thought of again. She also had to learn how to forgive herself. I enjoyed watching her thoughts and actions go through a transformation as this knowledge finally sunk in. She was finally free of her past, free to dream of a future.
Keondric had to learn to surrender to God. He tried so hard to make everything work and to be responsible for everyone, but it wasn’t working. Only God can take a mess and untangle it. He alone knows the future and how everything will play out. Seeing Keondric finally surrender his control was fantastic!
I loved the strong spiritual themes. These are things so many of us need to learn, or perhaps simply remember.
Elizabeth’s writing was superb! The descriptions were so real, that I often felt as though I was actually there, running through the streets with them, or peering over someone’s shoulder as I add my two cents to the plan!
My only complaint is that the story seemed a bit slow at first, as I tried to keep up with shifting view points and directions changing as she sculpted the story. Though, after a couple chapters it began making more sense, as I caught up and I was quickly absorbed in it!
I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys historical romance and suspense! Though, I would suggest reading the others in the series first.
I received this book from the author for my honest review, which I have given. I was not required to write a positive review and have not been compensated for it in anyway. All opinions expressed are my own.
Tide and Tempest is the final book in Elizabeth Ludwig’s Edge of Freedom series and I’m sorry to see it end! I loved Roarke, Cara, Eoghan, Ana, Tillie, and now Keondric! I became so attached to them! They were like great friends! But, the wonderful thing about books is that I can go back and “visit” them again.
I had loved Tillie’s character since the beginning and couldn’t wait to see where Elizabeth would take her story. I’m very happy to say that it was even better than I had imagined. The new members of the cast were interesting and everyone was well rounded. I hope Cass one day receives his own story! I loved him! (sorry if that is a spoiler)
Keondric may have been my favorite hero, I’m not sure. Though I did love Roarke and Eoghan, too. He was the prefect match for Tillie and brought out the best in her, which was fun to see, since she was rather quiet in the other books.
This is a book about forgiveness and surrendering our plans to God. Tillie had spent the last 10 months of her life feeling guilty and believing God would punish her for her past, or that she must pay penance for her sins. She had to learn that when God forgives, it is gone. He washes the sin away, never to be thought of again. She also had to learn how to forgive herself. I enjoyed watching her thoughts and actions go through a transformation as this knowledge finally sunk in. She was finally free of her past, free to dream of a future.
Keondric had to learn to surrender to God. He tried so hard to make everything work and to be responsible for everyone, but it wasn’t working. Only God can take a mess and untangle it. He alone knows the future and how everything will play out. Seeing Keondric finally surrender his control was fantastic!
I loved the strong spiritual themes. These are things so many of us need to learn, or perhaps simply remember.
Elizabeth’s writing was superb! The descriptions were so real, that I often felt as though I was actually there, running through the streets with them, or peering over someone’s shoulder as I add my two cents to the plan!
My only complaint is that the story seemed a bit slow at first, as I tried to keep up with shifting view points and directions changing as she sculpted the story. Though, after a couple chapters it began making more sense, as I caught up and I was quickly absorbed in it!
I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys historical romance and suspense! Though, I would suggest reading the others in the series first.
I received this book from the author for my honest review, which I have given. I was not required to write a positive review and have not been compensated for it in anyway. All opinions expressed are my own.
r_j_setser's review against another edition
5.0
The Synopsis:
“Two years ago, her fiance perished
during their voyage to America.
Now she discovers it may have been murder…
Dreaming of a better life, Tillie McGrath leaves Ireland behind and, with her beloved fiance by her side, sets sail for America. But when illness robs her of the man she holds dear, she’s left alone with only a handful of tattered memories. While forging on proves difficult, Tillie soon finds some new friends at her New York boardinghouse, and begins pursuing a new dream–to open a home for orphaned children.
Despite two years passing, Captain Keondric Morgan has never forgotten the lass who left his ship so heartbroken. When a crewman’s deathbed confession reveals her fiance’s demise was the result of murder, the captain knows he must try to contact her. But his attention draws the notice of others as well–dangerous men who believe Tillie has in her possession something that could expose their crimes. And to their way of thinking, the best way to prevent such an outcome is to seize the evidence and then hand Tillie the same fate as her naïve fiance.”
My Review:
This book was fantastic! I have not read the first two books in the series, but I had no difficulty following the storyline and would recommend it to all of my friends.
The characters were great. They each had their own personalities and dreams, they made mistakes and they were heroes, and they were just fun to read about. The story was also very interesting and I had a great time reading it. Again, I highly recommend this book to my friends and look forward to reading more from Elizabeth Ludwig.
“I received this book from Bethany House Publishing for the purpose of this review. All comments and opinions are my own.”
You can read more of my reviews at acceleratethejesusmovement.wordpress.com
“Two years ago, her fiance perished
during their voyage to America.
Now she discovers it may have been murder…
Dreaming of a better life, Tillie McGrath leaves Ireland behind and, with her beloved fiance by her side, sets sail for America. But when illness robs her of the man she holds dear, she’s left alone with only a handful of tattered memories. While forging on proves difficult, Tillie soon finds some new friends at her New York boardinghouse, and begins pursuing a new dream–to open a home for orphaned children.
Despite two years passing, Captain Keondric Morgan has never forgotten the lass who left his ship so heartbroken. When a crewman’s deathbed confession reveals her fiance’s demise was the result of murder, the captain knows he must try to contact her. But his attention draws the notice of others as well–dangerous men who believe Tillie has in her possession something that could expose their crimes. And to their way of thinking, the best way to prevent such an outcome is to seize the evidence and then hand Tillie the same fate as her naïve fiance.”
My Review:
This book was fantastic! I have not read the first two books in the series, but I had no difficulty following the storyline and would recommend it to all of my friends.
The characters were great. They each had their own personalities and dreams, they made mistakes and they were heroes, and they were just fun to read about. The story was also very interesting and I had a great time reading it. Again, I highly recommend this book to my friends and look forward to reading more from Elizabeth Ludwig.
“I received this book from Bethany House Publishing for the purpose of this review. All comments and opinions are my own.”
You can read more of my reviews at acceleratethejesusmovement.wordpress.com