This was a really great read, actually.

I am fascinated by small towns, and Bissinger does a great job of explaining all the history, socioeconomics and tradition that come along with small-former-boom-town Texas.

Dear Mr. Bissinger,

I think watching the Intelligent Squared debate you were in is great. I loved the television series based on this book. I learned something about myself while reading this. Even good writing such as yours, does not make me care a whit about football.

I gave it three stars because it is very well researched; and very well written. I was tempted to rank it lower though, only because it so depressing; its not so much about a dream but more of a fantasy. Its about a system and town that abuses and uses up its youth all the name of getting a state title.

Very well-written and I can understand why it's had the impact it did; at the same time, it's very dated and not really in my realm of interest. Would have enjoyed it more with a more sociological, systemic lens, and/or personal reflection.

I didn't grow up in a football-watching family. My father, who apparently loved the game, passed away when I was young. My mother was much more interested in baseball, and had coworkers with season tickets, so I grew up going to the Kingdome to watch Ken Griffey Jr., Randy Johnson, Joey Cora, Edgar Martinez, Jay Buhner, Dan Wilson... I even spent my high school prom night at Safeco Field, watching Freddy Garcia pitch a great game against the Yankees (who he'd eventually join, years later, sigh) instead of going to the dance. My high school football team certainly wasn't any good, and had I'd known that my college football team (Hofstra) would eventually a) have so many pro-level players, and b) get entirely nixed a few years after I'd graduated, I might've gone to more than one game. Maybe.

I came to football late in life, and have grown to love the game for any number of reasons. My knowledge of football certainly has a ways to go, still, but I do admit to being a total sucker for player stories and backgrounds - it's part of the reason why I fell in love with the Seahawks when Pete Carroll and John Schneider came along and shook things up - they found themselves a bunch of guys who were hungry to prove themselves, who'd been told over the course of their careers that they weren't good enough. If you saw this year's Super Bowl, you know how that worked out.

I say all of this because while I love football now, if you'd have told me a few years ago that I'd fall so in love with a book about football, I probably would not have believed you. But the thing is that the television show version of "Friday Night Lights" has a lot to do with why I opened my eyes to football to begin with, because much like Friday Night Lights the book - it's about so much more than football.

Friday Night Lights takes place in Odessa in the '80s, which becomes its own sort of character - an oil-boom town that never quite recovered from the bust, full of people living it up, thinking they were invincible... but then that whole business in the middle east was sorted out, and gas prices dropped off, and millionaires and banks in Texas found themselves broke.

Odessa was also dealing with its own particularly stagnant brand of race relations in the '80s, so much so that they had segregated schools for so long that eventually the government came in and said, "No, really, you can't do this anymore." But of course, once they realized that Black people were good at football, they were far more accepting, and drew town lines based on what demographic of people lived where (so that Permian could get more Black people). Yikes.

Most of all, Friday Night Lights is about the team and the coaches of Permian - the character traits and flaws that brought them failure and success, the single moments in games that came to define them, the dreams they held of greatness and the reality of life post-football, the toxicity of being held on a pedestal at such a young age contrasted with the question of, if they hadn't had football to be great for, then what?

Even though I totally understand why Bissinger uses the distinguished H.G. at the front of his name, a part of me wished he used his nick-name, "Buzz," because it perfectly describes his prose. His writing is just teeming with energy, with life, like the humming of a street light or a telephone wire. Bissinger shines when he's writing about people - their hands, the way that they eat, the look in their eye - you feel as though you've met them before.

I also was a bit sad by the fact that the most recent time I remember Bissinger being in the news was when he wrote about his shopping addiction - it made for a rather depressing juxtaposition when he was writing about issues of class and economics in Friday Night Lights so gut-wrenchingly well. At the same time, though, there's clearly something in him that deeply identifies with some of the bigger picture issues here - the striving for something seemingly greater, wanting to fill some kind of void. If he uses designer suits instead of football, I suppose that's just his poison of choice.

Whether your interest in the sport falls at zero or 100%, Friday Night Lights is an incredible look at the role that sports play in a community - the good and the bad - and an incredible study of Odessa, the '80s, the educational system, high school kids... so much more than just football - but plenty of that, too.

Update, Oct. 28: Continuing my "watching the movies of the books I've read this year" project, as I'm also a big film lover, I watched the movie adaptation of this, though I'd seen it before. The main problem is that this book is about so many things - the history of the town, the lives of the people in it, and obviously, football. To distill the book to just the football portions is to miss a lot of the point - which is by no means the movie's fault, since that's the most adaptable aspect. But, having read the book, I can see why making the film was not totally satisfying for Berg, and why he went on to make a TV show about it - there's just too much under the surface to get into during a two-hour film. The movie is much more faithful to the book than the TV series, which is more "inspired by" the people and the place as it is loyal to the story of anything that actually happened. Still, even though it's not connected to the story in the book at all really, the TV show does capture the same spirit, the idea that football is what gives this run-down town a purpose and a dream, what gives these people hope and possibly a chance to escape, or at least gives them glory days to wax poetic about when they've put away a six-pack...

I was surprised at how much I ended up liking this book. Non-fiction and sports books aren't my favorite, but Bissinger writes well, gives an open-minded assessment of the Odessa culture (both the good and bad), and he creates a rich story. By focusing on several of the main players and their journey to the playoffs, he allows the readers to come alongside the team and the town and feel the emotions of each game.

The earlier chapters on the history of Odessa, the oil industry, and the politics of the town were helpful, but tedious to read through. I loved the sections on the individual players and the coach, and my favorite chapters were the ones dealing with the controversies of the Carter Cowboys along with their game versus Permian. I was so engrossed with the story during the game--Bissinger does an amazing job in those climactic moments!

There are many interesting and disturbing issues to be discussed from this book: the explicit and implicit racism, the prioritizing of sports over education in school, and the role of sports and dreams in the lives of young people. I am looking forward to discussing this book with my students!

At times this book could be slow to read but overall I found to be enjoyable/eye opening. The fact that it's 1987 and Odessa is still not desegregated was one of the more eye opening parts of the book. Growing up on the east coast before this I found it very hard to understand how this way of thinking was still so prevalent. On top of that the emphasis of high school football over academics and students health was another mind boggling part. I can't imagine a world where students don't have to participate in school yet are expected to play a high school football game with broken ankles and arms. SPOILER ALERT: I was very disturbed that so much emphasis is put on these sports that it can potentially ruin a kids life like how Boobie amounted to almost nothing because he put all his eggs in one basket and found out that's not the only thing in life. I am glad the book was able to shed some light on the drastic level of thinking in this community and they were able to take a step back and reassess their ways of thinking.

This just wasn't my cup of tea.

This is a book that I would not have normally read. I am not a big sports fan and this book is all about American high school football. Once I started reading I could hardly put it down. It turns out to be a very human look at the players and people involved while also being an exposé of everything wrong with the American education system. The book is now 25 years old and the 10 year Aforward update some aspects of the story. An enjoyable read that left me shaking my head at time. Waste young lives and their potential to entertain adults may not be the best way to run a school.